“If you want to plan for a year, plant rice. If you want to plan for 10 years, plant trees. If you want to plan for 100 years, educate the children.”
— Confucius
Our purpose on the board of Pittsburgh Public Schools is to educate the children. My belief is that we are failing badly in educating our students — all students. Even more worrisome, the educational achievement gap between white and black children in Pittsburgh Public Schools is persistent and has not been reversed. The racial achievement gap over the last three years shows a continuous, unacceptable failure in the basic subjects of reading, math and science. Black children, in mostly black schools and in integrated schools, continue to lag far behind white children in these fundamental academic subjects.
Millions of dollars have been spent over this time period on “reform” programs that have not altered the achievement deficits. Slogans and aspirational goals do not create real, lasting change. Substituting new, unproven programs for old, failed programs also does not create real change. Instead of proven reforms, the administration has offered yet another new slogan — “Imagine PPS” — apparently to be coupled with the previous ineffective slogan, “Expect Great Things.”
We now face a critical inflection point in Pittsburgh Public Schools. The board will soon be asked to vote on another annual budget, with virtually no hope that the new budget will improve academic achievement for black or white students. The budget for 2020 is 2.4% larger than last year’s budget. Indeed, the annual budget for our schools has grown year after year, along with annual operating deficits, eating away at our once-generous fund surplus. Yet, we have received no budget narrative that explains why our budget continuously grows and why we are not reducing our expenses and deficits. Further, as our budget grows, our student enrollment continues to decline.
It is time for us to stop pretending that slogans are educational achievement programs. Now the administration has asked us to approve the first property tax increase in five years — an increase of 2.3%. No expense or deficit reduction.
Read More
The idea of a tax increase has received a very chilly public reception amid negative recent news coverage regarding the superintendent’s group trip to Cuba, his travel budget and other questionable expenditures. Not only has the tax increase proposal received a chilly general reception, but the mayor and other public officials have made negative comments about it.
Although it isn’t included in this year’s budget proposal, the administration has surprised city officials with the suggestion that the tax revenue that was diverted from the school district in 2004, to aid the city when it was in Act 47, be returned to the school district. This proposal also has not been well received. The mayor has said he would fight it.
The Pittsburgh Public Schools administration owes the board and the taxpayers a justification for why we should support an increased budget and increased tax burden in the face of dwindling student enrollment and academic failure. What is the plan for the allocation of the increased revenue, and how will these revenues assure improved academic outcomes?
In the absence of convincing answers to these questions, my vote will be “no,” and I hope my board colleagues will vote likewise.
Sala Udin represents District 3 on the Pittsburgh Public Schools board of directors.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.