The owner of 502 E. Ohio St. in Deutschtown — the landlord of Arnold’s Coffee & Tea, which faces eviction for unstable rent-paying history — is three years behind paying its taxes on that property.

For each of the years 2017 to 2019, 502 East Ohio LP, an entity created by the Historic Deutschtown Development Corp., owes $1,324.40, with a $66.12 penalty listed for this year on the Allegheny County real estate website.

Historic Deutschtown recently informed its property manager, the Northside Leadership Conference, that it has decided not to continue the lease of Arnold’s Coffee & Tea, in large part because the owner, Claudy Pierre, has been consistently late paying his rent.

He paid up as of September, including late fees.

Advertise with us

Mr. Pierre bought the business from Verna Arnold in 2018, but 502 E. Ohio Street LP was in arrears a year before that.

“We understand the situation with our tax obligation,” said Barbara Burns, board president of Historic Deutschtown. “It doesn’t help when you have a tenant who hasn’t been able to pay his rent consistently, with a number of bad checks returned.

“We do have debt service obligations to meet, and it helps when you have for-profits meet their obligations.”

She said Verna Arnold paid her rent on time.

The tax delinquency before this year owes in part to the financial challenges of improving the structure, including upstairs apartments, Ms. Burns said.

Advertise with us

“We intervened to bring back a building that had been vacant for six years,” — the former Wheeler’s Paint store. “Our intervention may have stabilized the structure.”

She said the nonprofit is considering options and strategies including refinancing the building and cited the challenges of being a nonprofit trying to goad the market into action. “We’re trying to make the buildings perform.”

Asked whether the owner or the project manager might have $1,324.40 somewhere to cover those taxes, Mark Fatla, executive director of the leadership conference, said each development project “is designed to be sufficient on its own based on its revenue stream. There isn’t a pile of cash here that fills gaps.”

Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com or412-263-1626. Twitter@dnelsonjones.