Three thousand people, as of Wednesday morning, have signed a petition on Change.org to support Arnold’s Coffee & Tea in Deutschtown on the North Side, whose lease is in jeopardy one year after chef Claudy Pierre bought the business at 502 E. Ohio St.
Leann Younger, a nearby resident, initiated the petition to convince the building owner, Historic Deutschtown Development Corporation, and its property manager, the Northside Leadership Conference, to protect what she and others call a community asset.
Consistently late rent payments, returned checks and, more recently, a rat infestation, prompted Historic Deutschtown to go to magistrate’s court. Even though Mr. Pierre paid in full as a result, Historic Deutschtown’s president Barbara Burns, in a letter to the leadership conference last week, noted that the garbage problem continued and that the group decided to terminate the lease.
Mr. Pierre said having caught up on what he owes, including late fees, should put him in the clear. He also said that the rat infestation was overstated, that he has not had a consistent problem with rats and that he sees that as an excuse for Historic Deutschtown to violate his lease.
Mark Fatla, executive director of the leadership conference, said his staff has worked to help Mr. Pierre with operations, marketing assistance and dealing with issues around trash throughout the year.
“It’s not like this stuff just popped up,” he said. “Yes, he got current on his rent but there’s other stuff... the rat infestation and the fact he is a serial violator. I can’t pay debt service if he’s not paying his rent. He has been three months behind twice in a year.”
Read More
Mr. Fatla said there is “an assumption that we can’t find another community-related business or a minority-owned business, but we have had interest from both.”
Mr. Pierre said the owners told him that their board “doesn’t feel like you can handle the lease,’” he said. “Well, who’s going to be able to handle it? Do they know? I’ve been busting my ass every day.”
The rent of $2,800 a month for a double-storefront “isn’t horrible,” he said, “but realistically, it could be better. We face challenges,” including illicit dealings on the street. “You come in here and it’s like night and day.”
Arnold’s became a magnet when retired public school principal Verna Arnold opened it in 2015. With fresh-cut flowers, exposed brick and warm lighting, it sells a wide variety of teas, coffee, sandwiches and pastries. Most mornings, tables are filled with people holding meetings, negotiating business deals, conducting interviews and doing remote office work.
Both owners have opened the space for community meetings and workshops.
The succession of black ownership was purposeful, and some petitioners urge the landlords to support that: “We need to keep some blackness on the North Side,” wrote Christina Giles in the petition. “They trying to kick us out like they did in East Liberty.”
Nick Kyrazi, a member of the East Allegheny Community Council, in Deutschtown, said he doubts the motive is racial.
“We have our meetings there,” he said. “No one wants to see them leave. I can’t imagine that [as a motive]. The leadership conference has been desperately trying to lease space.”
Mr. Pierre was building a catering business when he became a regular patron at Arnold’s. He briefly owned Culture Restaurant and Lounge Downtown, after working in restaurants including Steelhead Grill, Eleven and Nola.
In August, for a story about minority-owned businesses, he told the Post-Gazette that he had Ms. Arnold’s blessing to buy her out but doubted he could get financing because he had bad credit and trouble keeping up with the lease and repairs at Culture. Ms. Arnold helped finance the nearly $250,000 purchase, he said.
Mr. Pierre said people have texted him almost non-stop in recent days of their concerns.
Supporter Brennan Kaye wrote in the petition that he held all his meetings with clients at Arnold’s, “Arnold's is what got me to visit the North Side in the first place! I moved to Summer Hill This place is a crucial element of what makes the neighborhood a community. You take that away for mistakes a good lot of us make, you take away something irreplaceable.”
Gina Grone, president of the board of the East Allegheny Community Council, said she wants to remain neutral but that a for-profit landlord likely would not have given Mr. Pierre a year.
“At the 6-month mark, they’d say ‘We’re done.’ What the landlords did was, in my mind, provide leniency.”
Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1626. Twitter@dnelsonjones.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.