Eleven candles flickered in a store window in Squirrel Hill. Shortly after sunrise on a rainy Monday morning, owner Brad Perelman unlocked the front door of Pinsker’s Judaica, a Jewish gift shop and bookstore that has sat along Murray Avenue since 1954, and stepped inside. Behind him, a day-old sign still taped to the door read, “Closed Because of Yesterday.”
That sufficed.
“Yesterday” was Saturday.
“Yesterday” was terror.
On Monday, two days after a gunman killed 11 and wounded six more at Tree of Life Congregation, the weekday whir returned to Squirrel Hill. Initially, the scene on Murray and Forbes avenues didn’t appear out of the ordinary for a Monday, but then there were police barricades and news trucks stationed a few blocks away. And a helicopter slowly circling.
“How did this happen in our community, in our neighborhood, that anti-Semitism and hate is at our front doorstep?” asked Leah Kamon of Squirrel Hill. “It’s hard to reconcile that. It really is.”
Read More
•
Keith Kaboly, the manager at 61C Cafe on Murray Avenue, was looking out the shop window Saturday morning when he saw an ambulance racing up the hill. He recognized the EMT sitting in the passenger seat — a former barista at the cafe — and waved as the ambulance whizzed past. Next, a firetruck flew by, followed by a steady parade of police cars for over an hour.
“One bad person,” Mr. Kaboly said Monday. “Thousands of people rushing to help.”
Mr. Kaboly has worked at the cafe, which his aunt and uncle own, for 25 years. His daughter now works with him. “I’ve looked out the window for many, many years,” he said. He hopes he’ll never see another day like Saturday. Customers in the cafe heard the news and started calling anyone who might be at the synagogue. One person had a panic attack and went home.
Once the shock subsides, Mr. Kaboly said, it will give way to conversation. There will be debates over gun control and security protocols. For now, there are neighbors to help. Mr. Kaboly pulled a crumpled piece of paper from his pocket. A rabbi had asked him to send over pastries for a gathering at a nearby synagogue. The toaster oven has been running nonstop.
“I think this is bringing people closer,” Mr. Kaboly said.
Recently, Mr. Kaboly has silently feuded with Richard Greenberg, Squirrel Hill’s “Kilt Man.” He doesn’t remember why. But they haven’t spoken for a year. On Sunday morning, Mr. Greenberg walked into 61B Cafe, the sister shop in Regent Square. He saw Mr. Kaboly there and smiled.
“Water under the bridge,” Mr. Kaboly said. “We’re best friends again.”
•
While he fetched coffee Monday morning on Murray Avenue, Michael Milch of Squirrel Hill, reflected on whether his neighborhood felt any different than it had before the weekend. “It’s a bit quieter,” he decided. Something friends had told him Saturday afternoon was still on his mind. “They [said] for the first time they felt a sense of fear in Squirrel Hill,” Mr. Milch said.
Mr. Milch said he felt the community coming together. He went to synagogue Saturday night, and his parents were among the thousands at the vigil Sunday at Soliders & Sailors Memorial Hall & Museum in Oakland. “I think things are beginning — slowly, maybe — to move in a direction of connectedness,” he said.
Around then, James Tate, a Christian Zionist, walked past and removed his Steelers cap to show a black kippa underneath. He was wearing it to show support to the Jewish community, he said.
Standing near Congregation Beth Shalom on Beacon Street, Arlene Wolk tried to process what lay ahead. She had two funerals to attend Tuesday, she said, and more later in the week.
“I can’t even describe to you how some of us feel,” Ms. Wolk said. “Those were our friends that we prayed with every week. … I can’t minimize the pain. It’s going to take time to heal — for all of us. For Pittsburgh. For the country. I think for the world. This kind of hate crime …”
She paused.
“I hoped it would never happen in Pittsburgh.”
Teddi Horvitz, who visited the Tree of Life victim memorial with Ms. Kamon, said she still feels “100 percent safe” in Squirrel Hill. When she heard about an active shooter Saturday, her husband was at a synagogue. She immediately rushed out to find him. “I never felt unsafe here. I don’t think I ever will. We can’t let one person destroy what has been here for so many years.”
However, Ms. Horvitz said, having also lived in New York at the time of the 9/11 attacks, “I think, sadly, we’ve become a little bit numb to [the violence]. Because we’ve seen this before.”
•
At 1:30 p.m. Monday, while Robert Bowers was appearing at the federal courthouse in Downtown, a gathering began at Weinberg Terrace, a senior living facility a block off Murray Avenue. About 40 residents sat in the lobby and listened as a cellist played and a rabbi prayed for healing and peace. Most of the residents knew someone injured or killed at the synagogue.
“Never have I been so happy to see each and every one of you,” said Rena Becker, executive director of Weinberg Terrace. (She is also the mother of Pittsburgh Post-Gazette news reporter Andrew Goldstein.) “So happy that you’re safe. So happy that you’re here.”
“Hate cannot trump love and tolerance. I refuse to believe it can,” continued Ms. Becker, who went to Hebrew school with two of the victims, brothers Cecil and David Rosenthal, and was close with their family. “I think this was a cowardly act by a very sick individual. He hurt some of the most vulnerable people in our community. If that’s not cowardly, I don’t know what is.”
Weinberg Terrace went into lockdown after the shooting began Saturday. One resident had planned to attended services at Tree of Life that morning but didn’t feel well. He stayed home.
Deborah Winn-Horvitz, CEO of the Jewish Association on Aging, shared with residents the emails she’d received from other senior citizen organizations from around the country. One came from Audrey Weiner, the former CEO of The New Jewish Home in Manhattan. Ms. Weiner wrote that elders provided “resiliency” for the community after the 9/11 attacks.
“One Holocaust survivor told our chief psychiatrist, ‘The sun will shine again,’” Ms. Weiner wrote. “It did, but differently.”
Near the end of the service, the residents were asked if they had anything they wanted to say. One by one, they did. With wavering voices, they shared their memories of the victims. They wore agony on their faces. Some were confused. Some were upset. A man seated in the second row struggled to his feet, balancing himself with his cane, and said, “I have one question.”
“In the 82 year of my life: Why the hate for Jews?” he asked. “Why do they hate us? I haven’t found out the answer. I heard one man say to me years ago, ‘Oh, some of my golf partners are Jewish.’ So what? Why? We are good people. We are generous people. We are loving people. We have the state of Israel. We have the memory of 6 million Holocaust victims.
“I’m angry. And I’m sad. Why?”
•
Around the corner, back on Murray Avenue, a bouquet of white roses is threaded through the door handle at Pinsker’s Judaica. Outside, it’s late afternoon. Inside, there’s darkness. The candles burn brightly in the window. The same sign is taped to the door: “Closed Because of Yesterday.”
Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.