The redevelopment of the former LTV coke works in Hazelwood is meant to be one of the region’s premier projects — a showcase for design, public spaces and cutting edge sustainability, from the reuse of rainwater to net-zero energy.
But one thing not found in the preliminary plans for Hazelwood Green is firm commitments on affordable housing, despite the 3.8 million square feet of residential envisioned for the 178-acre site.
On the surface, it’s a curious omission, given that affordable housing has become such a hot-button issue in the city. Mayor Bill Peduto has championed it, a trust fund has been established to advance it, and the deed transfer tax has been raised to help pay for it.
Rather than specific targets, the Hazelwood Green preliminary land development plan states only that “diversity of housing also ensures a mix of affordability to provide for a range of household ages, sizes, and income levels.”
For some affordable housing advocates, that’s not enough.
“That’s an ominous sign. They’re talking a good game about preserving people in that community. If it’s not clearly delineated in the plan right now in the every beginning, it most likely won’t happen in the end,” said Randall Taylor, a member of the Penn Plaza Support and Action Coalition.
Read More
He believes there should be specific guidelines, even at this early stage of planning.
“We know it’s a serious issue. That’s the first thing you should do to send a message to Hazelwood that it is going to be different than East Liberty,” he said, referring to the East End neighborhood where gentrification and displacement have become a growing problem, as highlighted by the Penn Plaza controversy.
Those affiliated with the redevelopment say the lack of specific goals at this point is mostly by design. They said they are collaborating with the Hazelwood community to determine how much affordable housing is needed — both on the site and in the neighborhood as a whole.
Specific targets will come once a plan to address affordable housing in the neighborhood and at Hazelwood Green has been completed, said Rob Stephany, director of community and economic development for the Heinz Endowments.
Heinz, the Richard King Mellon Foundation, and the Claude Worthington Benedum Foundation own the former mill site under the name of Almono LP.
“Making up an artificial number is not a real commitment,” Mr. Stephany said. “We want to figure out ... who needs what, when and where and then bring forth a strategy with solutions.”
Including specific guidelines for affordable housing in a preliminary land development plan isn’t without precedent.
In approving the Pittsburgh Penguins’ preliminary plan for the former Civic Arena site in 2014, the city planning commission required residential developers to submit a plan showing that “reasonable efforts” had been made to make 20 percent of the nearly 1,000 units affordable.
That is the goal the team had committed to in a community agreement it negotiated with Hill District leaders related to the lower Hill site.
Lack of affordable housing also was an issue in a preliminary land development plan for the former Penn Plaza site in East Liberty rejected by the planning commission early last year. The developer eventually dropped plans for about 200 apartments at the site in favor of offices.
R. Daniel Lavelle, the city councilman who co-chaired the task force that recommended the creation of a fund to develop and preserve affordable housing in the city, said he was a bit surprised that the Hazelwood Green preliminary land development plan didn’t include more specific goals.
“But as slowly as the foundations have been able to move on that entire initiative, it’s not that surprising either. But I would expect the foundation community to be sensitive to this issue,” he said.
Likewise, city Councilman Corey O’Connor, who represents Hazelwood, emphasized after a recent community meeting the need for affordable housing at the site.
“That’s really important to me, and to a lot of the residents I’ve heard from today — that they want to be part of Hazelwood Green,” he said. “I definitely want affordability . . . That’s not a debate. I think we have to.”
Not to worry, said Mr. Stephany and others.
Sonya Tilghman, executive director of the Hazelwood Initiative, said her organization, along the foundations and other community partners, are just starting a process to determine long-term affordable housing needs in the neighborhood.
That is expected to produce an eventual agreement on how many affordable units will be built at Hazelwood Green and how many in the neighborhood, she said.
“We feel we really get closer to those answers through this affordable housing piece we’re doing,” Ms. Tilghman said.
Mr. Stephany estimated that overall there could be a need for as many as 400 units of such housing — “just a guess” — in the neighborhood and at Hazelwood Green.
Beyond the community plan, he expects two parts of the preliminary land development plan to hold the foundations accountable to produce affordable housing at the old mill site.
One is the LEED for Neighborhood Development designation that Almono LP it is seeking. Another is the P4 principles — people, planet, place and performance — it is adhering to as part of the redevelopment.
The foundations, Mr. Stephany stressed, “want to build a great place for everyone. We don’t want to build a place that is exclusionary.”
Nonetheless, Laura Wiens, director of Pittsburghers for Public Transit, another group that has advocated for more affordable housing in the city, said she, like Mr. Lavelle, was a bit surprised to learn that the foundations did not include specific goals for such housing in the Hazelwood Green preliminary land development plan given their support for such initiatives in the neighborhood and elsewhere.
“They could be a model for what affordable housing should look like in the city,” she said.
Staff writer Rich Lord contributed to this story. Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.