The changes in housing-related tax deductions under the new federal tax act would have an almost imperceptible impact in the Pittsburgh region, economic and real estate experts said.

“Pittsburgh is likely to be hurt less hard than places like New York and California because of their higher tax rates and higher land values than Pittsburgh,” said Kurt Rankin, a PNC regional economist who covers the upper Midwest, which includes Pittsburgh. “Pittsburgh home prices are 10 to 20 percent less than the national average. That changes the impact.”

Though there were several financial and real estate analyses over the past few weeks that predicted that changes to the mortgage interest deduction and cap on state and local income and property tax deductions would reduce home values by 4 percent or more nationally, experts say that is unlikely to happen here.

“In terms of [the tax act’s] impact on housing prices, Pittsburgh is kind of in the middle of the road compared to the Northeast and West Coast,” said Adam Kamins, a senior economist at Moody’s Analytics. “The lower your housing prices area, the less impact this bill has.”

Advertise with us

The two big changes in the tax act were to reduce the value of a mortgage from $1 million to $750,000 from which interest could be deducted from federal taxes, and to cap at $10,000 the amount of state and local income and property taxes that could be deducted. The state and local tax deduction was previously uncapped.

Tax plan: Pittsburgh area less affected among metro areas Compared to homeowners in other regions with higher home values and taxes, relatively few in our region would be affected by two of the federal tax changes in the recently approved bill: the reduction of the mortgage amount from which you could deduct interest — from $1 million in mortgage value to $750,000 — and a $10,000 cap on the amount of state and local income and property taxes you could deduct. PERCENT OF HOMES WITH $750,000 OR MORE IN MORTGAGE VALUE

Created with Highstock 6.0.49.9%9.9%7.8%7.8%4.8%4.8%4.5%4.5%4.4%4.4%4.1%4.1%3.3%3.3%3.1%3.1%3.1%3.1%2.8%2.8%0.1%0.1%Percent over 750k1. San Francisco-Redwood City-South…1. San Francisco-Redwood City-South San Francisco CA2. San Jose-Sunnyvale-Santa Clara CA3. Bridgeport-Stamford-Norwalk CT4. Anaheim-Santa Ana-Irvine CA5. Oakland-Hayward-Berkeley CA6. Los Angeles-Long Beach-Glendale…6. Los Angeles-Long Beach-Glendale CA7. Oxnard-Thousand Oaks-Ventura CA8. San Diego-Carlsbad CA9. Urban Honolulu HI10. Silver Spring-Frederick-Rockville …10. Silver Spring-Frederick-Rockville MD86. Pittsburgh PA024681012

PERCENT OF HOMES WITH OVER $10,000 IN PROPERTY TAXES

Created with Highstock 6.0.446.5%46.5%33.7%33.7%22.7%22.7%20.6%20.6%19.9%19.9%18%18%12.4%12.4%11.8%11.8%11.4%11.4%10.8%10.8%2%2%Percent over 10k1. Long Island NY2. Newark NJ3. New York NY4. Fairfield County CT5. San Francisco CA6. San Jose CA7. Boston MA8. Chicago IL9. Austin TX10. Cambridge-Newton-Framingham …10. Cambridge-Newton-Framingham MA43. Pittsburgh PA01020304050

Advertise with us

Source: Trulia; Post-Gazette

“The greater Pittsburgh housing market won’t much be affected by the federal tax plan, since only a very, very small share of properties have, or would come with, mortgages greater than the new $750,000 cap and/​or property tax bills greater than new $10,000 cap,” said Ralph McLaughlin, chief economist for Trulia, an online real estate information service that analyzed markets nationally.

Trulia analyzed the 100 largest metropolitan statistical areas (MSA) in the country and found just 513 homes in the Pittsburgh MSA — which includes Allegheny County and the six surrounding counties — with mortgage values over $750,000.

That was just 0.1 percent of all Pittsburgh area homes with mortgages, ranking Pittsburgh 86th on the list.

Because Pennsylvania has relatively high taxes, though, the region ranked higher on a Trulia analysis of homeowners who pay $10,000 or more in property taxes.

Advertise with us

Trulia found that 14,144 homeowners in the Pittsburgh region pay $10,000 or more in property taxes. That is just 2 percent of all homeowners, ranking the region 43rd on the list.

Matt Vermiere, government affairs director for the Realtors Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh, said it’s not surprising that the region does not have many homeowners who will be affected by the housing-related changes to federal deductions.

“In general we get ranked well for housing affordability,” he said. “We just have a lot of quality old housing stock.”

Of the two big changes, he thought the reduction in the mortgage value that interest could be deducted from would have a bigger impact on high-priced property owners’ decision than the cap on income and property tax deductions.

“In areas like Squirrel Hill and Shadyside [where more expensive homes exist] you might see an impact,” Mr. Vermiere said.

Advertise with us

The main reason, said Mr. Kamins, the Moody’s economist, is that under the existing tax law “property taxes and mortgages were partially subsidized by the law,” and negatively changing that “reduces the incentive to buy a home.”

Moody’s Analytics predicted that the Pittsburgh region would see lower housing values in the 2 percent to 4 percent range because of the tax bill.

Mr. Rankin, the PNC economist, does not think that will occur, however.

“Someone would have to work very hard to convince me that homes values would fall in Pittsburgh because of the tax bill,” he said.

He points out that the same areas that Moody’s and others are now predicting would see housing values fall the most because of the tax act — coastal cities, Chicago and others — were the same areas that were hurt during the Great Recession in 2009.

Advertise with us

And Pittsburgh’s housing values, he points out, “rose during the Great Recession.”

Though the cut in mortgage interest deduction and state and local tax deduction might end up being a disincentive to buy homes in high home value areas like New York, “those same arguments don’t work in Pittsburgh,” Mr. Rankin said, in part because of the “minuscule numbers of people it affects in Pittsburgh.”

“We’re talking about an individual here not buying a home because of a loss of about $2,000 in deductions,” he said. “That probably isn’t going to affect a decision to buy a home here” for most homeowners.

Mr. Rankin warns that the fact that the Pittsburgh region will not be as affected by the loss of housing-related deductions “has good news and bad news in it, unfortunately,” he said.

Lower prices for homes and wages are a big reason why the cost of living in Pittsburgh has stayed low.

Advertise with us

“But that means the demand for people to live in Pittsburgh is not nearly as strong as The Most Livable City awards would suggest,” Mr. Rankin said.

The region essentially has had no job growth since 2000, he said, and would have had a reduction in jobs in the last 17 years if not for some recent job growth since 2012.

Low unemployment “is an indication that we’re not drawing in new residents.”

As another example, he pointed out that the region is the 12th largest in the country for health care employment, but we’re ranked in the bottom third of metro areas in the country in job growth.

“It’s not resting on our laurels, but we’re not taking advantage of the opportunities we have,” he said.

Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill