Pennsylvania’s top fiscal watchdog urged rapid changes Wednesday in both oversight and financial management at the Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority, pressing for a more independent board and tighter business practices.

“The average, everyday Pittsburgher wants clean water and a bill they can afford to pay. And the current structure of the authority cannot meet these two very basic desires,” state Auditor General Eugene DePasquale said Downtown, where he introduced a broad audit of PWSA.

Both City Council and the authority board sought the review as city leaders examine PWSA’s widespread service failures and how to reorganize the agency. More than 300,000 people rely on its water and sewer infrastructure, which the city leases to PWSA under arrangements that began in 1984.

Euguene DePasquale discusses his office's audit of the PWSA

Mr. DePasquale blamed the set-up — namely an updated agreement in 1995 — for planting PWSA “on a collision course of financial disaster.” The city has long diverted resources from the authority into other local needs, while leaving PWSA with a heavy debt load, according to his office’s 55-page report.

Advertise with us

Now, Mr. DePasquale said, PWSA and the city should rework their relationship to help shore up authority finances and limit rate increases for customers. He also favors partnerships with private entities to raise money, he said, rather than relying only on higher rates to fund system improvements.

His audit focused on whether controls and decision-making at PWSA were “adequate to provide effective oversight.” Reviewers made a single finding: that years of mismanagement and conflicted leadership led to the authority’s poor technical condition, financial stress and a governance crisis.

Seventeen recommendations range from better customer service to loosened residency requirements for PWSA workers. The authority said it’s already pursuing many goals encouraged in the state report, including dramatic increases in infrastructure spending expected over the next decade. A 2018 budget-and-rate proposal is due before the PWSA board next week.

Among other findings and recommendations in the audit report:

  • Under the 1995 agreement, PWSA should provide the city up to 600 million gallons of free water each year. Yet some 90 percent of city-owned properties have no water meters, so PWSA doesn’t know how much water is flowing into several hundred of those facilities. PWSA should meter and track water usage at all city-owned properties — and bill the city for any usage over 600 million gallons a year.
  • PWSA board members should not hold paid jobs with the city. Four of seven sitting members are city employees, including city Councilwoman Deborah Gross. Current practices put certain city officials on the board. The mayor appoints board members with council approval. But “PWSA should either be a separate, independent authority” or operate directly as a city department, Mr. DePasquale said. “The city-compensated [board] members may be influenced by the wishes of their employer, the city mayor’s office, despite the board members owing a fiduciary duty to the entity [PWSA] they serve and its customers,” the report reads.
  • PWSA can’t charge for about half the clean water it produces, due in part to leaky pipes that can’t be found. Annual capital improvements were about $31.4 million from 2012 to 2016 but should have been at least $200 million. That trend has contributed to — and compounded — infrastructure failures, such as more than 3,500 pipe breaks since January 2014.
  • A residency requirement mandates that PWSA workers live in the city, but interviews conducted in the audit found that standard hinders hiring and retention. The rule should be relaxed to let workers live in the surrounding region.

The findings emerged just before a public workshop Thursday about the authority. Consultants looking into PWSA and restructuring options will convene the session at 5:30 p.m. at the South Side Market House, 49 S. 12th St. Their recommendations will go before a panel assembled by Mayor Bill Peduto.

Advertise with us

Mr. DePasquale said Mr. Peduto could chart a path forward using input from that panel, the audit report and state lawmakers. Asked whether the Peduto camp had contributed to PWSA mismanagement, Mr. DePasquale said the administration “maybe didn’t move fast enough” on reforms.

“That’s where we disagree with the auditor general,” said Mr. Peduto, who is pursuing a second four-year term in Tuesday's general election. “They state both that we need to move faster and that we should be involved in the process. That’s why we’re in this problem: For 30 years, we haven’t been involved and we haven’t invested."

The mayor vowed that “my administration will be very involved and that we will invest.” In a written statement, he said the city would consider some of Mr. DePasquale’s recommendations. PWSA board Chairwoman Debbie Lestitian echoed the sentiment.

An authority capital plan calls for $1.5 billion in system work over the next 10 years, said Robert Weimar, the interim executive director.

“We’re talking about a long haul here,” he said. “This is not something that’s going to be done in a few years.”

Adam Smeltz: 412-263-2625, asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz.