The consulting firm hired to study the issues facing the Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority, which it described as “on its last leg,” outlined several options for municipal leaders to consider Monday as they work out how to improve the struggling agency.
The Washington, D.C.-based Infrastructure Management Group, hired this spring by PWSA and Pittsburgh City Council, gave the first of three presentations Monday as it leads an organizational review at the water authority. A panel appointed by Mayor Bill Peduto’s administration and tasked with plotting the way forward for PWSA heard from IMG Chairman Steve Steckler, who outlined potential restructuring options for the water authority and offered his firm’s preliminary observations about the issues facing PWSA.
The agency is tackling a host of problems, including a nine-figure debt load, failing infrastructure, leadership turnover, shortfalls in customer service and decades-old lead service lines that can contaminate tap water. Mr. Peduto has said the authority needs billions of dollars in long-term infrastructure improvements "after decades of disinvestment and neglect."
“What is needed is a holistic vision of how the utility will be improved,” Mr. Steckler told the panel. “Everyone has to buy in, because it’s going to be expensive. It’s going to be hard.”
He provided brief outlines of eight potential restructuring options to save PWSA, including “aggressive internal improvement;” transferring management of the utility to a non-profit, for-profit or government agency; outsourcing of selected services; making short-term improvements with the ultimate goal of regionalizing the entity with other municipal water agencies; contracting out the maintenance and operations; and entering into a concessions lease.
Each of those options has pros and cons, Mr. Steckler said, and each of them has implications for customers.
Read More
One option would be to transfer the city water and sewer utility to a private, non-profit, “public charitable trust,” similar to what Indianapolis did in restructuring its water and sewer utility and transferring it to Citizens Energy Group. But there is no comparable charitable trust in Pittsburgh with existing infrastructure assets and an independent utility operating structure, so one would need to be created to own the assets and manage and operate the water utility.
Another popular restructuring option would transfer PWSA assets to another government operating entity, typically a large regional authority with an existing customer base for the same or similar service, the study said. But the only potential restructuring partner of sufficient scale is the Allegheny County Sanitary Authority and IMG has not yet met with the authority.
The study identified “internal improvement” as the most common restructuring option, though warned that the “cost, effectiveness, sincerity and durability of these efforts has varied.” The option can include “radical changes” from board level governance to maintenance, or more modest changes to operating procedures, hiring practices and information systems.
An internal improvement option that eschews quick fixes in favor of more durable and sustainable long term strategies is more likely to be successful, the study said.
The risks to this approach can be reduced, the study found, when ownership of the assets and responsibility for operations are separated, as they are between the city and PWSA. The existing asset lease agreement between PWSA and city could be amended to enforce operational changes, and set “quantified goals and multiple milestones, readily measured, reported and made public.”
Mr. Peduto has said that selling the PWSA system to a private entity, an option included in the study report, is off the table. End insert His administration has promised an open, transparent process, including public meetings to address PWSA's future. IMG and the panel will hold similar meetings. Sept. 12 and Nov. 8, when IMG intends to release its final findings.
IMG's efforts represent the first phase toward a potential restructuring of PWSA. Any longer-term costs in that process have yet to be determined.
IMG has taken on similar work in at least 30 cities, Mr. Steckler has said. The city and PWSA expected to split as much as $550,000 in costs for the company’s work.
Elizabeth Behrman: Lbehrman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1590. Reporters Adam Smeltz and Don Hopey contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.