A man who was violently subdued by police outside the PPG Paints Arena on Tuesday was just trying to help, his lawyer said.
Attorney Phil DiLucente said on Thursday that his client, Daniel T. Adelman, 47, of Ravenna, Ohio, saw a physical confrontation Tuesday night between at least one police officer and a civilian and decided to get involved.
Officer Brian Markus wrote in an affidavit that Mr. Adelman ran at them during an arrest of someone else and ignored police commands to stop even after they identified themselves as officers. Two of the officers were in plain clothes; one was uniformed.
Officer Andrew Jacobs punched Mr. Adelman in the face as he “charged” forward and “took a fighting stance,” the officer wrote in an affidavit.
Then in an ensuing scuffle, Officer Jacobs punched Mr. Adelman in the face and chest several times while the man was on the ground, and at one point slammed Mr. Adelman’s head against the pavement while an officer shouted an obscenity, according to the bystander’s video.
Mr. Adelman was then subdued with a Taser. He was visiting Pittsburgh to attend a concert at PPG Paints Arena and did not know the man police were trying to arrest, Mr. DiLucente said.
Read More
Mr. DiLucente would not say who Mr. Adelman was trying to aid when he approached — but Mr. Adelman told Pittsburgh Post-Gazette news partner KDKA-TV on Wednesday, “I was smoking a cigarette, and I seen an officer with a suit on, and then I see this other guy and I thought the officer in the suit was in trouble.”
Phil DiLucente Press Conference
In a 54-second video clip of the incident captured by a bystander, Mr. Adelman is heard saying, “I’m trying to help you,” multiple times.
“I’ll be honest, that was my first instinct,” he told KDKA as he left the Allegheny County Jail. “But obviously that was the wrong decision in the end because I got beat up pretty good.”
Mr. Adelman approached three Pittsburgh police officers at the intersection of Lemieux Place and Centre Avenue around 10:45 p.m. Tuesday as they were attempting to arrest David Jones, 34, on an outstanding warrant.
Warning: Video contains offensive language:
Pittsburgh police arrest men near PPG Paints Arena
"It was not an intentional act to try to hurt law enforcement. It was not an intentional act to try to reach out and obstruct anything, but rather assist in the matter," Mr. DiLucente said.
Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala, Jr. and multiple city agencies are reviewing the officers’ use of force. Officer Jacobs has been placed on desk duty.
The five officers involved in the arrest — Officers Markus, Jacobs, Todd Modena, Francis Rende and Robert Palivoda — could not be reached for comment Thursday.
Mr. Adelman was charged with public drunkenness, resisting arrest and obstruction of law enforcement. Mr. DiLucente said Thursday that Mr. Adelman never intended to hinder law enforcement but would not go into detail about how Mr. Adelman intended to help.
"In no way was he attempting to resist arrest and/or obstruct any law enforcement because it was not an intentional act,” he said, adding later that it can be difficult for someone to hear police commands when “they are being stunned with a gun or...their head is meeting the pavement several times.”
Mr. Adelman is receiving follow-up medical attention for a dislocated shoulder, bruises on his head and concussion-like symptoms, Mr. DiLucente said.
The professional painter had been drinking that night, Mr. DiLucente said, but it was not to the point where “he didn’t know who he was.”
Mr. DiLucente added that he wanted to see additional video of the incident before he judges whether the officers used appropriate force.
Independent legal observers differed in their views of the confrontation. Russell Kolins, a security consultant in Philadelphia, said Mr. Adelman "should never have injected himself into police action.
"There was no way for the officers to know why he physically approached [them] under the emergent circumstances, hence officers had to weaken their approach to Jones as their team was depleted to take control of the unknown and unexpected attack by Adelman," Mr. Kolins wrote in a statement to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. "The depletion of manpower gave rise to Jones to further resist the officers."
Mr. Kolins, who has handled defense work for the Fraternal Order of Police in Philadelphia, said he would need more specifics to perform a complete analysis.
In Los Angeles, former federal prosecutor Lucas Rowe said the actions of the Pittsburgh officers appear to pass legal muster — with a possible exception.
"Slamming someone's head into the ground could be construed as use of deadly force, potentially," said Mr. Rowe, an attorney who focuses on police misconduct. He said it would be "hard to show that that was a reasonable act" under the circumstances.
Legal precedent holds that police can use "objectively reasonable" force given "the totality of circumstances," said Mr. Rowe, who worked as an agent for the U.S. Secret Service. He cautioned that events leading up to the recorded struggle, along with other details still unknown, "would be relevant in an ultimate conclusion."
"You're only seeing one angle. There could be other angles," he said.
Pittsburgh City Councilman R. Daniel Lavelle, whose district includes Uptown, said investigators are trying to cobble together more video and interviews from the incident. He said the partial footage circulating online disturbed him, adding that police actions appeared excessive.
"But before being definitive, I would like to gather all the facts," Mr. Lavelle said.
At the same time, he said, "I would probably say that probably more than one [officer] should be on desk duty.
"And if it does indeed prove to be excessive use of force, there's probably some sort of suspension warranted," Mr. Lavelle said. He said he has "full faith and confidence" in city police Chief Scott Schubert and Public Safety Director Wendell Hissrich to do "everything that's appropriate."
Shelly Bradbury: 412-263-1999, sbradbury@post-gazette.com or follow on Twitter @ShellyBradbury. Adam Smeltz: 412-263-2625, asmeltz@post-gazetter.com or on Twitter @asmeltz.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.