The Pittsburgh office of the FBI has opened a review into the violent arrest of an Ohio man earlier this week by five city police officers.
There are already multiple ongoing probes of the incident Tuesday night outside PPG Paints Arena which left Daniel T. Adelman, 47, of Ravenna, Ohio with numerous injuries that his lawyer said included a dislocated shoulder, bruises on his head and concussion-like symptoms.
"We are aware of the incident that took place outside of PPG Arena in downtown Pittsburgh on Tuesday evening, and we are reviewing the facts and circumstances surrounding the matter in close coordination with the United States Attorney's Office, Western District of Pennsylvania," Special Agent Robert Johnson of the FBI’s Pittsburgh field office said Friday in a statement. "If information comes to light of a potential federal civil rights violation, the FBI is prepared to investigate."
One police officer was put on desk duty after video shot by a bystander captured him striking Mr. Adelman at least eight times while he was on the ground before slamming Mr. Adelman’s head against the pavement. Officers used profanity while subduing Mr. Adelman, who was eventually shocked with a Taser.
"The City of Pittsburgh welcomes this review by the FBI, as it provides yet another investigatory layer to this incident. There is now an internal investigation by the Office of Municipal Investigations and another external review by the Citizen Police Review Board. We will support whatever it takes to get all the facts on this matter, and the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police will cooperate and provide any assistance necessary to the FBI during their review," Mayor Bill Peduto said Friday in a statement.
Mr. Peduto withheld judgment about the arrest.
Read More
“My reaction was just like everybody else's: Looked bad," the mayor told reporters Friday. "But I also learned the hard way during the Pride Parade when I saw a video that I thought looked really bad as well, that after investigation and even eyewitness accounts found the officer was not guilty -- the officer was innocent -- and so I'll wait to make final judgments, and I'll allow the investigations to continue without any prejudgment.”
Bill Peduto comments on police video
The mayor was referring to a 2014 incident in which Officer Souroth Chatterji punched, pushed and swung a Harmony woman by her head while trying to break up a fight during the PrideFest parade that June. He was taken off the street for a time but was eventually cleared of using excessive force.
The woman, Ariel Lawther, now 22, of Harmony pleaded guilty to two summary counts of harassment after being initially charged with aggravated assault, simple assault and other crimes after Pittsburgh police said she hit a protester and then struck an officer who tried to intervene in the chest and groin.
The Allegheny County District Attorney’s Office had a pending investigation of the Adelman incident, but its status is unclear.
“It is the longstanding policy of this office that if our office and the United States Attorney have a mutual interest in a situation and the USA makes a decision to pursue their interest, this office will not conduct a parallel investigation,” Mike Manko, spokesman for District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. said in a statement.
Mr. Manko declined comment beyond the statement and would not clarify whether the DA’s investigation is continuing.
Mr. Peduto Friday also responded to a letter sent to him, Public Safety Director Wendell Hissrich and police Chief Scott Schubert by Tim Stevens, head of the Black Political Empowerment Project, a local grass-roots advocacy group, and Valerie Dixon of the Greater Pittsburgh Coalition Against Violence, that noted the groups' efforts to foster better relations between police and the community in Pittsburgh.
Mr. Stevens and Ms. Dixon told the mayor that they viewed the incident with Mr. Adelman "as a setback to such efforts to project 'a new day in Pittsburgh policing.' "
"We must admit...that the initial viewing of Mr. Adelman's head being repeatedly pelted against the cement, while being beaten by other Pittsburgh police officers, is quite disturbing," the letter said.
"Much work has been accomplished in recent years to improve community-police relations in Pittsburgh. In order to not totally tarnish what has been done and accomplish, we ask that the examination and review of this incident be a high priority to all in your administration."
The letter asked for a review of police training.
Mr. Peduto said he did not believe that a single incident was representative of police-community relations.
“We’ll take action if necessary, but one incident should not be the determining factor of how our police having been working the past three years to build those community relations,” the mayor said.
He also noted that officers are trained in both martial arts and de-escalation techniques. Mr. Peduto added that he has spoken with Mr. Hissrich and Chief Schubert about bringing in outside resources to enhance de-escalation training.
Mr. Adelman and his attorney, Phil DiLucente, have said that the Ohio man was just trying to help when he saw officers making an arrest outside the arena at Centre Avenue and Lemieux Place in the city’s Uptown section Tuesday around 10:45 p.m. and decided to get involved. Mr. Adelman told KDKA-TV that he was trying to assist the police.
Police claimed in court paperwork that Mr. Adelman adopted a "fighting stance," prompting an officer to take action.
The bystander's nearly a minute-long video clip showed the officers violently subduing Mr. Adelman, who can be heard at the end repeatedly saying, "I’m trying to help you."
Mr. Adelman was charged with public drunkenness, resisting arrest and obstruction of law enforcement.
Officers involved in the matter were identified in court records as Brian Markus, Andrew Jacobs, Todd Modena, Francis Rende and Robert Palivoda. Officer Jacobs was placed on desk duty pending the outcome of reviews.
Mr. DiLucente declined comment Friday about news of the FBI”s involvement.
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg. Andrew Rush contributed to this story.
Letter to Mayor Peduto, Safety Dir Hissrich, Chief Schubert, Re Dan Adelman, Sept 22, 2017 (PDF)
Letter to Mayor Peduto, Safety Dir Hissrich, Chief Schubert, Re Dan Adelman, Sept 22, 2017 (Text)





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.