An audit by Allegheny County Controller Chelsa Wagner says the county health department should be doing more to proactively warn, educate and protect Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority customers about elevated lead in drinking water.

The health department disagrees, as it did with Ms. Wagner’s last audit of the department in December, calling this audit’s findings “misleading,” “biased” and deeply flawed.

The 30-page audit, released at a Tuesday afternoon news conference in Ms. Wagner’s office, alleged that the health department has failed to emphasize water as a significant source of lead exposure, hasn’t worked with public water suppliers to inventory and catalogue lead service lines, and doesn’t adequately investigate or publicize lead risks in water.

“I’m sorry to say we found much the same lack of action and denial of responsibility we found in our first review,” Ms. Wagner said at the news conference, adding that the health department has sought to “deflect attention from and minimize the risk of lead exposure from the public water supply.”

Advertise with us

The controller and the health department agree that human lead exposure from water, soil, paint, dust and toys is a serious public health problem, especially for children, and also agree that the incidence of elevated lead blood levels in Allegheny County is trending mostly downward. But their agreement ends where the audit begins.

In a six-page response letter included in the audit document, Allegheny County Health Department Director Karen Hacker strongly condemned the audit for failing to follow national public health agency data standards, inaccurate and incomplete presentation of county health department data and lead inspection and abatement programs, and “faulty conclusions … and inaccuracies.”

“This is misleading and biased and a potentially dangerous use of public health information that creates fear and confusion, and neither shapes the conversation around this important issue, nor informs the work of ACHD in this matter,” Dr. Hacker wrote July 17, after reviewing a draft of the audit. “We must dismiss these findings wholly, because of the misuse of the data and the lack of evidence provided.”

Following Ms. Wagner’s news conference, Dr. Hacker said the final audit provided no new information and does little to help solve the county’s lead problem.

A measure of the differences between the controller’s audit and the health department can be found in two graphs showing very different elevated blood level rates county-wide, in the PWSA service area and outside that service area.

Advertise with us

The controller’s graph shows blood lead levels above 5 micrograms per deciliter in 10.67 percent of children tested in the PWSA service area in 2013, 9.57 percent in 2014, 9.24 percent in 2015 and 9.28 percent in 2016.

A graph of the health department’s childhood elevated lead level rates, using methodology favored by the Centers for Disease Control, shows high but much lower rates: 5.22 percent in 2013; 4.68 percent in 2014; 4.39 percent in 2015, and 2.90 percent in 2016.

Nationally, the Centers for Disease Control has found that approximately 2.5 percent of children tested show elevated blood lead levels above 5 micrograms per deciliter. According to the CDC there is no safe level of exposure to lead, which can cause premature births, low birth weights, and miscarriages for pregnant women, and in children can cause brain damage, learning disabilities, lower intelligence quotients (IQ) and seizures.

Marc Edwards, an environmental engineering professor at Virginia Tech who has been recognized for his work exposing the Flint, Mich., lead water crisis in 2014, said at the news conference Tuesday that none of the methods for measuring lead exposure are perfect, and part of the problem is the existing federal lead and copper rule provides inadequate protections against lead water levels.

“Revisions have been pending for years and it looks like it will be several more years before any national guidance is clarified about how best to protect the public from elevated levels of lead,” Mr. Edwards said.

Advertise with us

He said advances in how even small amounts of lead affect health are changing the way water lead levels are viewed.

“I have to question the motives of anyone who downplays lead water level concerns,” he said. “This is a problem that needs to be taken seriously. We need to work on preventing all exposures.”

On the most basic level, Dr. Hacker wrote in her response letter, the controller misrepresents the role of the health department’s public drinking water program. The health department performs inspections and non-penalty compliance reviews, but the state Department of Environmental Protection is responsible for permitting, issuing orders and assessing penalties.

Dr. Hacker noted that the tenor of the audit suggests the health department hasn’t done enough to protect public health, but said the department has been involved in programs to reduce lead exposure for decades and that “suggesting in any way that ACHD has been derelict in its duties to protect the health of residents of the county misrepresents the daily work that hundreds of employees do on behalf of those residents each day.”

The county Board of Health, along with Dr. Hacker, also issued a joint statement Tuesday afternoon condemning the audit as “inaccurate and wrong.”

Advertise with us

Dr. Hacker, who is heading the recently created county Lead Task Force, noted that the department has advocated that the federal action level for lead in water be lowered from 15 to 10 parts per billion, and in May the Allegheny County Board of Health unanimously approved a requirement that all young children in the county be tested for lead exposure beginning in 2018.

She said the health department has continued to operate its lead investigation program despite losing funding, has trained young people to canvas low-income and minority communities to talk about lead exposure sources and health effects, and recently received foundation funding to hire a lead epidemiologist to assess lead test data.

The Lead Task Force has been meeting regularly and gathering information, Dr. Hacker said, and intends to release its report, including recommendations on how to address the multiple lead problems

“I think,” she said, “we have been committed to this issue and are providing information and updates to county residents as fast as we can.”

Don Hopey: dhopey@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1983, or on Twitter @donhopey.