The contested Whole Foods Market redevelopment effort in East Liberty is bound for formal court arguments by next month.
A month of closed-door discussions between the city and Pennley Park South, an affiliate of LG Realty Advisors, has yielded no agreement over the controversial plan at the former Penn Plaza apartments site, attorneys said Friday.
At a Downtown status conference, Allegheny County Common Pleas Senior Judge Joseph James said he would expect formal legal briefs within 30 days. Pennley Park attorney Jonathan Kamin said his clients had made “great concessions” to attempt an agreement, including an offer of 20 percent affordable housing in the project’s second phase.
“Based on the city’s response, it seems clear to us that they're interested in just killing this project,” Mr. Kamin said. “At this point, we’re happy to go ahead and to have our day in court.”
City solicitor Lourdes Sanchez-Ridge denied that claim. She said the city wants to ensure the project follows law, zoning codes and conditions imposed by city leaders.
“That’s all we're trying to do — and to protect those citizens,” Ms. Sanchez-Ridge said, referring to the people who still live at Penn Plaza. The city last month sought an injunction to stop alleged demolition activity at the remaining apartment building and to ensure “a decent, sanitary building” for the tenants there.
Read More
City officials claimed the developer began demolition work before the March 31 deadline for all residents to move out and that it had failed to supply proper heating, all in violation of an agreement struck last year.
Mr. Kamin has disputed the complaint. He said Friday that workers began removing cabinets from vacant units and started other pre-demolition work, but had not done any actual demolition.
The developer suspended those preparations last month out of courtesy and at significant expense, Mr. Kamin said. He said more than 200 residents have been relocated, receiving — collectively — hundreds of thousands of dollars in relocation help from the developer.
Fewer than 20 residents remain at Penn Plaza. As of Friday, Mr. Kamin said, only two had yet to line up future homes in time for the March 31 deadline. He said both had been offered housing elsewhere.
“We have bent over backwards and backwards and continue to bend over backwards,” he said. Earlier, in court, Mr, Kamin said it appears the city wants to delay demolition “forever.”
Asked how long the city believes tenants should be able to stay, Ms. Sanchez-Ridge told reporters that she could not answer.
“We certainly can’t knock it down if it’s not vacant,” Judge James said. “That would be difficult.”
Before the city filed its complaint, Pennley Plaza claimed it had “deemed approval” to proceed with redevelopment after the city planning commission failed to supply written notice of its rejection of the developer’s amended preliminary land development plan plan within the appropriate time frame. The city has disputed that.
The 50,000-square-foot Whole Foods would replace a smaller store on Centre Avenue. The redevelopment plan also includes 200 apartments, 12,000 square feet of offices and 582 parking spaces in the first phase.
Adam Smeltz: 412-263-2625, asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz. Staff writer Mark Belko contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.