A dispute between Pittsburgh city officials and the developer of the Penn Plaza site in East Liberty continues to escalate.
A letter last week from city solicitor Lourdes Sanchez-Ridge to Jonathan Kamin, attorney for Pennley Park, an affiliate of developer LG Realty Advisors, noted a litany of grievances from the building’s few remaining tenants.
Among the complaints listed, “that the heating units of several apartments are not functioning well enough to meet the Allegheny County’s Health Departments’ requirement. …There are residents who have experienced, and continue to experience very low temperatures in their apartments causing them to use alternative heating sources such as space heaters, numerous blankets, multiple layers of clothing and even their ovens. This situation creates a dangerous condition to these residents, some, [of] whom are elderly.”

Maura Donnelly of the North Hills joins several dozen demonstrators Tuesday outside the City-County building, Downtown, in support of Penn Plaza residents. (Nate Guidry/Post-Gazette)
Additionally, the letter stated there are complaints about potential asbestos exposure, allegations of rodents on the premises, and non-residents “entering the building and intimidating the residents.”
The letter states if these problems are not fixed, the developer will be in breach of a 2015 agreement governing how residents would be relocated.
Read More
The residents, many of whom are low-income, are being displaced to make way for an upscale development, and the issue has become a rallying point for those concerned about gentrification and rapidly changing city neighborhoods. The remaining residents are due to leave by March 31.
Mr. Kamin disputed the city’s characterization. He said Pennley Park “has gone to great lengths to make sure that the building remains safe and habitable at all times.”
“We have responded to every single maintenance call and have serviced the units when needed,” he said. “This is a well-orchestrated, coordinated effort by a small number of residents who are not interested in living up to their contractual obligations.”
Mr. Kamin said the city and the Allegheny County Health Department have inspected the building and found no violations. Some residents, he maintained, have left windows open in their apartments and then complained about the heat. Readings taken by Pennley Park in multiple units have shown temperatures ranging from 67 to 72 degrees, he said.
Pennley Park has removed some ceiling tiles to seal off vents, in part to help keep the building warm. It is not doing any asbestos abatement, Mr. Kamin said. It also has “maintained the same extermination and pest control schedule we’ve always had and when there is a concern, we promptly address it.” He said he was not aware of complaints about nonresidents entering the building.
A protest took place at the City-County building downtown Tuesday over the matter. Following the demonstration, Kevin Acklin, chief of staff for Mayor Bill Peduto, met with about 25 residents and protesters.
“We wanted to bring attention to the residents that are still there,” said Randall Taylor, a former resident, “and we also wanted to bring attention to the larger issue of affordable housing and gentrification.”
Earlier this month, city officials cited the developer for removing 10 trees without authorization. Prior to that, the developer filed a lawsuit, following the city planning commission’s rejection of its amended plan.
The planned development includes a 50,000-square-foot Whole Foods, 200 apartments, 12,000 square feet of offices and 582 parking spaces.
“We have no problem with new things. But it cannot be at the expense of the people who built this city,” said Mr. Taylor.
Kate Giammarise: kgiammarise@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3909 or on Twitter @KateGiammarise. Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.