City officials have cited the developer behind the proposed Whole Foods Market at the Penn Plaza site in East Liberty for removing 10 trees without authorization.

The Forestry Division of the Department of Public Works is demanding that Pennley Park South Inc. pay $42,000 to replace trees removed within the city right of way adjacent to 5600 Penn Avenue and the Penn Plaza site.

In the citation, forester Lisa Ceoffe said the trees were removed without first obtaining permission or a permit from the city. She referred to a section of the city code that prohibits anyone from removing or cutting down a tree in a public street or public place without first obtaining a permit.

Jonathan Kamin, attorney for Pennley Park, an affiliate of developer LG Realty Advisors, said “We have acted in accordance with the law and the applicable rules and regulations at all times. We wish that the city would act in the same manner. We have done nothing wrong, and look forward to vigorously defending these citations.”

Advertise with us

The citation is the latest salvo in the escalating battle between the developer and the city.

Last week, city solicitor Lourdes Sanchez-Ridge accused Pennley Park of taking actions, such as cutting down trees, in violation of the code and the decision by the city planning commission rejecting the developer’s amended preliminary land development plan. She ordered Pennley Park to “cease and desist.”

At the time, Mr. Kamin refused to do so, saying Pennley Park, owner of the Penn Plaza site, was in “complete compliance with the law.” He said trees were being removed as part of Pennley Park’s plans to demolish a second apartment building at the site. Those removed would be replaced in compliance with city law, he added.

However, Ms. Sanchez-Ridge said the developer was supposed to give the city a plan for replacing the trees and hadn’t done so.

Earlier this month, Pennley Park filed a lawsuit against the city charging that the amended preliminary land development plan rejected in January actually had been deemed approved because the panel did not provide written notice of its decision within the appropriate time frame.

Advertise with us

As a result, Mr. Kamin said Pennley Park planned to move ahead with its development, which includes a 50,000-square-foot Whole Foods, replacing a smaller one on Centre Avenue, as well as 200 apartments, 12,000 square feet of offices and 582 parking spaces.

Mark Belko: mbelko@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1262.