Can humans hold off computers again?

Rather than the plot of a sci-fi movie sequel, that’s the question at the heart of part II of a battle that begins next week at Rivers Casino between Carnegie Mellon University’s poker-playing computer and four of the world’s best human, Heads-Up, No-Limit, Texas Hold ’em poker players.

“It is important to all of us to give humans the best showing possible,” said Jason Les, one of the human players coming to Pittsburgh next week, sounding every bit the part of a sci-fi movie character. “The day is coming when computers will win. We know that. I just want to hold out as long as possible.”

Dubbed by CMU as “Brains Vs. Artificial Intelligence: Upping the Ante,” Mr. Les and his three colleagues — Dong Kim, Daniel McAulay and Jimmy Chou — will begin play on Jan. 11 in the poker room at the casino. They will play 8 hours on each of 20 straight days of 120,000 total hands (30,000 hands per player) against the computer, and to see which of the four players gets the largest share of the $200,000 pot.

Advertise with us

They will be matched against Libratus, the newest iteration of famed CMU computer scientist Tuomas Sandholm’s decade-long project to build a computer program that can learn, and even think its way to regularly beating humans in the most complicated version of one-on-one poker.

Of course, the end game to this research is not to win at poker.

“I’m interested in fundamental research, and a lot of that theory is incorporated into this bot,” said Noam Brown, a CMU Ph.D. student working with Mr. Sandholm. “I definitely see [the research that goes into Libratus] being applied in the future to programs for negotiations or cyber security and other applications, any situation where you have hidden information.”

Nearly two years ago, the humans (including Mr. Les and Mr. Kim) narrowly defeated Mr. Sandholm’s prior incarnation, Claudico, by a theoretical $730,000 out of about $170 million wagered during the games, though no real money was played.

Experts then were predicting that with the rapid improvements Mr. Sandholm’s team was making, that regularly beating humans was going to happen within five years at the most.

Advertise with us

So is this the time? Will this be the IBM-beats-Kasparov-at-chess moment?

“I harbor hopes,” Mr. Sandholm said.

Despite the fact that Libratus beat the prior incarnation of the program, Baby Tartanian 8, last year, and Baby Tartanian 8 beat its predecessor, Claudico, which narrowly lost to the humans, “you can’t say Librartus beats the humans,” he said. “It doesn’t add up like that.”

“The humans may also have changed their strategy, too,” he said.

That’s exactly what the humans are saying they’re doing.

Advertise with us

“We’ll work together to represent the humans,” said Mr. Kim.

Nightly review sessions – which the players credited with keeping them ahead last time – will be part of the strategy this time, too.

“Hopefully technology hasn’t caught up with us quite yet,” Mr. Kim said.

Mr. Sandholm and Mr. Brown have, of course, made their own changes in strategies since 2015, some of which can be seen through the name change.

“Claudico,” which means “limp” in Latin, was, in part, designed to use a limping strategy in its poker play, something the human players last time thought did not work as well as it should.

Advertise with us

“Libratus” is Latin for “balanced” or “powerful.”

This program was created from scratch, Mr. Sandholm said, and involved more than five times as many computational hours working out its algorithms than Claudico did. A major goal is for it to have a “balanced” strategy so that an opponent can not anticipate what it will do in similar situations.

Most of this competition will be identical to the 2015 event: Heads Up, No Limit, Texas Hold ’em poker played in matched pairs, whereby one of the human players will play the same cards against the computer that the computer is playing against another player who is isolated from the public. Two human players will play at a time in the poker room for public viewing from 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. with an hour for lunch, while the other two play alone in separate rooms in the casino.

But some changes were made to accommodate both the CMU team’s requests and the humans: To try to get to “statistical significance,” the players will play 50 percent more hands this time — going from 80,000 hands to 120,000 hands, and play will increase by a week to 20 days. To try to reduce the length of the playing day, players will be allowed to play two hands at a time — something they do regularly on their own anyway — to take time advantage of any slowdowns in play by the computer.

In addition, to attract these four highly ranked players, the pot was doubled — from $100,000 to $200,000 to be split up among the human players based on their performance — thanks to an increase in sponsorship.

Advertise with us

Craig Clark, Rivers’ general manager, said it was an easy call to agree to host the competition again, and not only because it will draw worldwide attention with the live streaming of hands viewed 284,000 times on the online site Twitch.

“People were asking [after the first competition]: ‘Is there going to be a rematch?” he said. “Plus, it’s only fair to have a rematch to see if the computer will win, or if the humans can hold them off. Even though they know it’s inevitable.”

Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill