Pittsburgh City Council could decide as a group whether to discipline any members who divulge certain information from closed-door meetings, according to a proposal presented Tuesday.
An earlier draft would have let the council president alone determine whether to impose such sanctions, including fines up to $500. But Bruce Kraus, the sitting president, said a shared approach would prevent a consolidation of power.
Mr. Kraus introduced the plan as part of proposed operating rules for council, which is set to take up the 19-page legislation Nov. 2. He said the discipline provision reflects “the severity of the breach.”
“This is not about secrecy. This is not about closed doors. It’s about the sworn duty of council to protect the public and to protect the public purse,” Mr. Kraus said.
Under proposed language, a council member at an executive session could be fined or censured for disclosing “information determined to be attorney-client privilege.” While transparency advocates have warned that such a move could spark lawsuits on free-speech grounds and chill open discourse, Mr. Kraus said council should safeguard the private meetings.
Council can use executive sessions to discuss only legal, personnel and a few other matters listed under state law. Breaking the confidentiality could compromise the city’s legal standing and open it to millions of dollars in losses, some council members said.
Read More
“Actions that hurt the taxpayer need to have consequences,” said Councilwoman Natalia Rudiak, who served on a subcommittee that crafted the proposed council rules.
Mr. Kraus said council has faced a violation of executive session privacy, although he declined Tuesday to discuss specifics. Last week, he said Councilwoman Darlene Harris once removed confidential documents from an executive session and shared them with the news media.
Mrs. Harris repeated Tuesday that she did not recall such an incident. She plans to oppose the fine provision if council doesn’t allow for an appeal process, she said.
“It appears as if they’re putting in a gag order,” Mrs. Harris said.
At the Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association, media law counsel Melissa Melewsky said the changes to the earlier proposal draft didn’t make the measure any more palatable. Among the revisions, language that would have allowed the council president to punish non-elected city employees for executive session leaks has vanished.
“There’s nothing in state law that says you can’t discuss what happens in executive session, whether it’s affected by the attorney-client privilege or not,” Ms. Melewsky said. She said she had not heard of such fines before.
Still, at the Chateau-based Local Government Academy, interim executive director Preston Shimer said he saw merit in the idea.
“I guess there should be a consequence for every rule you have,” Mr. Shimer said, “and this falls into that category.”
Adam Smeltz: 412-263-2625, asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.