Revealing too much from closed-door meetings could become a costly proposition for Pittsburgh City Council.

Proposed changes to council’s operating rules would allow fines up to $500 against members who disclose certain material from executive sessions, which often involve legal or employment cases. Council President Bruce Kraus said Wednesday that the idea is to safeguard attorney-client privilege — and council itself — when members address sensitive issues.

But several legal observers questioned the legitimacy of the plan, arguing that proposed sanctions could open city officials to federal lawsuits over the constitutional right to free speech. City solicitor Lourdes Sanchez-Ridge said her office is reviewing the text, including for First Amendment concerns.

“I’m not sure that the city council would have the legal authority to create such a penalty,” said Craig J. Staudenmaier, a Harrisburg attorney who handles transparency cases. He said he knows of no similar provision anywhere in Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

Mr. Staudenmaier said the state Sunshine Act enables municipal bodies to hold executive sessions, which the act limits to union negotiations, legal consultations and a few other categories. The law lists no allowance for local officials to impose punishment over information-sharing from those gatherings, said Terry Mutchler, former director at the state Office of Open Records.

She said the penalty approach could “leave a bad taste in the mouth of the public.”

“These types of things generally are ill-advised because the reality is, [council] members already have a duty to keep confidential information,” said Ms. Mutchler, who leads the transparency practice at the Pepper Hamilton law firm in Philadelphia. She said the discipline threat could “send a jolt through folks and make them think twice before they talk to the media.”

Proposed changes also could subject city workers to unspecified discipline if they attend and spread select information from an executive session, according to the draft. Like council members, they could face sanctions if they “have been found to divulge information determined to be confidential by the [city] solicitor and have a probability to impair the ability of the solicitor to defend a claim or lawsuit,” the proposal says.

For anyone in violation, it would be up to the council president to decide on a punishment. The language is among a bundle of proposed rule changes that Mr. Kraus and a council subcommittee developed over the past couple of years. He said their full draft should go before council at its regular meeting Tuesday.

Advertise with us

Councilman Corey O’Connor, who helped with the document, said the penalty provision is meant largely to prevent the distribution of critical legal paperwork, not so much to keep council members mum.

“Someone has to be accountable if you’re going to take a legal document that could cost the city money and distribute it to the world,” he said.

Still, Mr. O’Connor left open the possibility that council could abandon the penalty proposal, which he said was not a “gag order.” He said he knew of no instances in which a council member shared a private legal document with a party suing the city.

But Mr. Kraus said Councilwoman Darlene Harris had taken confidential documents from an executive session and shared them with the media. A frequent adversary of Mrs. Harris’, he said that occurred in the past couple of years but could not recall many specifics.Asked if the penalty proposal was designed for Mrs. Harris, Mr. Kraus said he was “not going to go there.” He emphasized that the subcommittee had worked for years on council rules.

“We didn’t just sit down and say, ‘How can we penalize Mrs. Harris?’” he said.

Advertise with us

Mrs. Harris said she felt targeted and did not recall distributing material from an executive session.

“Maybe under his definition of ‘executive session,’” added Mrs. Harris, who has criticized Mr. Kraus over closed-door meetings not classified as executive sessions. “But I was not elected by Bruce Kraus to this council.”

At the Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association, media law counsel Melissa Melewsky said the fines would amount to “a government restriction on speech” and “deter people from bringing issues to light.”

“Any time we get government controlling speech, it’s a problem. On its face, that’s what this policy seeks to do — control the way people communicate about government,” Ms. Melewsky said. “It’s just not a good idea.”

Adam Smeltz: 412-263-2625, asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz.