Marilyn LeResche had received numerous phone calls over the years from authorities saying they might have found evidence that could lead them to a suspect in her mother’s killing, but none of the information ever led to anything.

Twenty-five years after Myrtle L. McGill was shot to death in her home in White Township in Indiana County, Ms. LeResche, 67, a retired school administrator, finally got the call she had been waiting for — there was an arrest.

Pennsylvania State Police and the Indiana County District Attorney’s office announced Tuesday that a homicide charge had been filed against a 61-year-old man from Magnolia, Minn., though they would not identify the suspect. Officials said more information would be released at a news conference Friday at the Indiana County Courthouse.

“This makes me feel hopeful that there will be justice,” Ms. LeResche said Tuesday evening from her home in El Cajon, Calif. “A case is never closed. It can be cold, but new information can come forward at any time. I’m grateful to the people who have followed up all these years.”

Advertise with us

A detective with the Indiana County District Attorney’s office found Mrs. McGill, 76, dead in the kitchen of her home on the afternoon of Dec. 13, 1991. The county coroner at the time, Thomas Streams, said it appeared that Mrs. McGill, a widow who lived alone, had been shot multiple times in the chest days earlier. She was last reported seen Dec. 7.

Investigators said Mrs. McGill had been shot with a small-caliber handgun through the front window of her large, split-level home. Nothing was missing except her car.

The 1982 Ford Crown Victoria was found Dec. 9 — four days before her body was discovered — in a leased parking space at a business on Penn Avenue in Pittsburgh. The owner of the company called police, who determined no one had reported the car stolen and had it towed. A state trooper investigating the death was at the McGill home Dec. 14 when a letter arrived from the towing company.

Investigators said they found no fingerprints or other evidence in the Ford.

Friends and neighbors were shaken by Mrs. McGill’s death. They could not believe anyone would want to harm the churchgoing wife of a prominent Indiana County businessman.

Advertise with us

Everett “Curly” Hilliard, who in 1973 bought McGill Motors, a Ford dealership, from Mrs. McGill’s husband, Lewis, said that although he didn’t know Mrs. McGill well, “she was a nice person and she was always very kind to me.”

Mr. Hilliard, 83, of White Township, said Tuesday that he wasn’t too surprised by news of the arrest because the Indiana County Sheriff’s Department had contacted him a couple of months ago. He said he was told investigators were close to naming a suspect, and he was asked whether he had any more information than what he had given to police 25 years ago. He said he was shocked then to learn that the case was still open.

“I thought this had been put on the shelf and nothing was ever going to happen with it,” Mr. Hilliard said. “I said, ‘You’re kidding.’”

Law enforcement officials in Indiana County and Rock County, Minn., would not provide further information about the suspect Tuesday other than to say he was in police custody.

But news of the arrest brought some solace to Ms. LeResche, who has wondered for 25 years whether she would ever find out who killed her mother, and why.

Advertise with us

“It sure would be great to have some closure,” Ms. LeResche said. “Now there might be some justice for her.”

Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352.