A Common Pleas court judge must decide if two teens accused of killing another at a Carrick group home should be tried as adults.

Yusuf Shepard, 16, has asked that his case be moved to juvenile court, which would only have jurisdiction over him until the age of 21. On Tuesday, Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey A. Manning presided over a decertification hearing on the matter. Yusuf’s co-defendant, Malik Crosby, had a similar hearing in January.

Judge Manning said he would take the matter under advisement.

Both teens are charged with killing Nicholas Grant, 16, who died on Jan. 13, 2015.

Advertise with us

Nicholas died three days after, police said, he was placed in a choke hold by Yusuf at the former Circle C Youth and Family Services home, where they were staying.

During testimony on Tuesday, experts for both the prosecution and defense spoke about whether Yusuf would be amenable to treatment in the juvenile system. Both experts said they were unsure if spending slightly more than four years in treatment would be adequate.

Alice Applegate, who has a doctoral degree in psychology, testified on behalf of Yusuf, saying that he had a childhood filled with trauma and stress. He is one of 12 children, she said, and in the year before the incident, “his family was imploding. They were shedding children.”

Ms. Applegate said that Yusuf is immature and uses avoidance to cope with problems.

Both Ms. Applegate and the commonwealth’s expert, Dr. Bruce Wright, said that Yusuf described the incident to them as having been instigated by Nicholas, who previously had threatened to shoot him like a "sniper" and threatened to stab him.

Advertise with us

The night of the incident, on Jan. 10, 2015, Nicholas threw a vacuum cleaner at Yusuf, Dr. Wright said.

The two teens began to scuffle, and Yusuf described putting Nicholas, who was grabbing his hair, in a chokehold.

"'I'm going to kill you when you let go,'" Yusuf said Nicholas told him.

"He told me he was afraid to let go," Dr. Wright recalled Yusuf saying.

But, the psychiatrist continued, another witness at the group home, said she did not recall hearing those things being said. She did recall saying that Nicholas was turning blue, and still Yusuf didn’t let go.

Advertise with us

Dr. Wright agreed with Ms. Applegate that Yusuf does not understand what led to his current charges. But, he told Judge Manning that Yusuf did feel sorry for what happened, and that he thinks about it every day. But he also said, “’I don’t feel I should be punished this way for something I had no control over.’”

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.