Two teenagers charged with killing a fellow resident of a Carrick youth home were held for court at a preliminary hearing Wednesday in Pittsburgh Municipal Court.

Malik Crosby, 16, and Yusuf Shepard, 15, are charged as adults with homicide, aggravated assault and criminal conspiracy in the death of Nicholas Grant, 16, at Circle C Youth & Family Service group home.

Their attorneys, Blaine Jones and Al Burke, respectively, intimated after the hearing they may seek to have their clients certified by the court as juveniles before they go to trial. Both attorneys also said their clients were defending themselves from Nicholas’ aggression.

Regardless, Mr. Jones added, the result was a tragedy. “I hurt for Mr. Grant’s family. This shouldn’t have gone so far. You would hope young people can put their emotions aside.”

Advertise with us

Attorney Todd Hollis, speaking for Nicholas’ mother, Leslie, said, “It’s difficult getting a call telling you that your child is dead, killed in a home supposedly entrusted for his safety and well-being. I have nothing but confidence there will be justice.”

Police said Nicholas was choked and beaten with a vacuum during a fight inside the home on Jan. 10. The medical examiner’s office ruled the death a homicide caused by “compression of the neck” creating a lack of oxygen in the brain.

The only witness to testify at the 50-minute hearing was Joylynn Grant, the counselor on duty the night of the fight, who is no relation to Nicholas. She testified that Yusuf and Nicholas had an argument that escalated to a physical fight after Nicholas pointed his finger at Yusuf’s face. The fight moved to the hallway and into the living room. She said she called 911 as soon as the fight began and yelled for them to stop.

At one point, they did, and the two combatants and Malik went into the dining room. Nicholas picked up a vacuum cleaner and threw it in Yusuf's direction and the fight began anew, this time with more intensity and involving Malik.

Yusuf got behind Nicholas and wrapped his arm around his neck in a chokehold while Malik was punching, kicking and hitting him, Ms. Grant testified. The fight moved into the kitchen, where Nicholas was forced to the floor, hitting his head on a counter in the process. He stopped fighting back so aggressively at that point, Ms. Grant said.

Advertise with us

Malik continued to punch and kick him and got the vacuum and hit Nicholas in the torso three or four times, she testified. “You don’t stop till the police get here,” she quoted Malik as saying. Ms. Grant said it took five to seven minutes for police to arrive. Yusuf didn’t release the chokehold until about two minutes before they got there.

“He was turning extremely purple,” she said of Nicholas. “It ended when he stopped moving.”

Upon arrival, police performed CPR. Nicholas was taken to UPMC Mercy, where he died three days later on Jan. 13.

Michael A. Fuoco: mfuoco@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1968.