The leaders of a Carrick youth home were negligent in hiring an employee charged with shoving a teenager down a set of concrete steps last year based on his criminal history, the boy's family said in a lawsuit filed this week.
Relatives of the boy, who is referred to in a complaint only as John Doe, are suing the Circle C Youth & Family Service group home, and the former employee, 36-year-old Jaymar Gilbert of the Hill District, alleging negligence, assault, battery and intentional infliction of emotional distress.
That is the same group home where police say a different teenager, Nicholas Grant, 16, was fatally beaten by fellow residents earlier this year.
Todd Hollis, the attorney representing both victims' families, said Mr. Gilbert "should not have ever been hired given his very detailed 10-year criminal history." Court records show Mr. Gilbert, who declined comment on Thursday, has pleaded guilty in the past to burglary, drug charges and a gun violation, among other crimes.
Those are "very serious crimes which would have called in to question a caregiver's fitness for providing direction to young boys," Mr. Hollis said.
Hollie Geitner, a board member at Circle C, said Mr. Gilbert passed three background checks -- one for child abuse offenses and others conducted by the FBI and Pennsylvania State Police -- and did not come back with any convictions for crimes that prohibit people from working with children under state law. She said Mr. Gilbert had "excellent references, including a lengthy recommendation from a local pastor" and was "very well-liked by the youth and the staff."
Read More
The group home, she said, sometimes hires people with criminal histories because, "We've found that having some staff who may have been in the system themselves or who have struggled with some of the very same challenges that the youth are experiencing can be the most effective in helping them turn their lives around."
Mr. Hollis said his client had been at the youth home a few months when Pittsburgh police charged Mr. Gilbert with grabbing him by the head and tossing him down a set of concrete steps outside the home on Carrick Avenue.
A report by the Pennsylvania Department of Public Welfare, now the Department of Human Services, indicates that another employee captured cell phone video of the altercation, and Mr. Gilbert, who was suspended without pay, could not continue to work with residents unsupervised.
Ms. Geitner said he later resigned "as a result of the restrictions that were placed on him by the state following the incident," as they left him "no longer able to perform his job duties."
Mr. Gilbert is scheduled to go to trial on one count of simple assault March 17.
Mr. Hollis said his client requires orthodontic surgeries as a result of his injuries and now has "an obvious distrust for adults that he doesn't really know."
"He suffered some injuries and we realized that the physical injuries heal very fast but the psychological ones tend to heal very slow, so we're trying to get him some help."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.