A plan to redevelop the historic Alfred E. Hunt Armory in Shadyside into an Olympic-size ice rink has come apart because the developer could not line up the necessary financing.

The demise of the East End project, which would have included a fitness center and sports medicine and rehab services, was announced Tuesday evening in an email from City Councilman Dan Gilman to residents and supporters who envisioned it as a boost to the neighborhood’s recreation opportunities.

Developer Gary Maister of Toronto-based Cadan Inc. notified the city that it was withdrawing from the project “due to lenders’ reluctance to finance ice rinks in light of recent rink closures in the region and the sports medicine groups we have been in discussions with deciding not to consummate leases.”

Mr. Gilman said he was “very disappointed,” but added, “I remain committed to working with the community on a new plan.”

Advertise with us

The Pittsburgh Urban Redevelopment Authority voted 4-1 in December to have Cadan Inc. convert the Emerson Street property into a family-friendly ice-skating facility with three rinks, a cafe, and a suspended walking and running track. There would have been 164 underground parking spots.

The ice palace proved popular with many residents who attended public hearings on the pitch, as officials opted away from a more bankable $2.5 million apartment complex for the site. Supporters, preferring “quality of life” over fast dollars, said they did not want to see more luxury apartments squeezed into one of the city’s most densely populated areas.

But the URA board’s approval did not come without strings. At a May meeting, the members spelled out 17 conditions the developers had to meet, including a minimum purchase price of the armory’s appraised $1.86 million value, and a commitment to complete the project without public subsidy.

Kevin Acklin, chief of staff in the mayor’s office, which supported the project, issued a statement saying, “We are evaluating next steps with URA staff and fellow board members, and assure that URA's actions on this development will continue to be aligned with the interests of the surrounding neighborhood.”

“While this proposed development will not move forward,” Mr. Gilman said in his email, “[the city] will go through a public, community-based process to find a project that meets the needs and interest of immediate neighbors, Shadyside residents, and all community members. We are just now beginning to evaluate our next steps, but I can assure you it will be a public process that you will be included in.”

Dan Majors: dmajors@post-gazette.com and 412-263-1456.