In the end, an Allegheny County judge bought only part of the explanation by two former Port Authority bus drivers for a 2014 accident and convicted them of summary offenses Thursday.

But although Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey Manning concluded that fired drivers Juliann Maier and Thomas Frauens were racing on Interstate 279 when Ms. Maier’s bus crashed off the side of the road, he cleared them of more serious charges, including a felony against Mr. Frauens, who had been accused of leaving the scene of an accident.

The judge fined Ms. Maier, 47, of Ross, $250 and Mr. Frauens, 57, of Brookline, $475, for a series of traffic violations including speeding and reckless driving. They also face a likely license suspension of six months.

Ms. Maier’s attorneys said they disagreed with the finding that she was involved in horseplay that led to the crash and will appeal the fine.

Advertise with us

Mr. Frauens will appeal only if the fines would prevent him from resuming his career as a bus driver.

Port Authority fired both drivers, but both are trying to get their jobs back. They have appealed through the drivers’ union and the case is awaiting an arbitration decision.

Prosecutors alleged that Mr. Frauens gestured to Ms. Maier to race shortly after they left the Ross garage and entered I-279 on Sept. 22, 2014. They contended that Ms. Maier’s bus struck the rear of Mr. Frauens’ vehicle, sending her off the road, as they jockeyed for position.

Ms. Maier’s bus landed on its side on Evergreen Road; she suffered a broken pelvis, four broken ribs and other injuries.

Ms. Maier and her attorneys claim her bus had a catastrophic brake and steering failure because of poor maintenance, causing it to crash. She testified she never saw any gesture from Mr. Frauens and wasn’t aware he was beside her because she was struggling to regain control of her bus.

Advertise with us

Mr. Frauens and his attorney said his “buggy whip” gesture was just routine “driver talk” and he wasn’t aware the buses had collided. He stopped several hundred yards from the accident, returned to see the overturned bus and left when another driver at the scene said she would report the incident to Port Authority officials.

Judge Manning agreed the condition of the bus was questionable but said Ms. Maier contributed to the crash by engaging in horseplay. He described her 13-year-old bus with 333,000 miles on it as one he “certainly wouldn’t want to drive or be a passenger in.”

“The court finds [Ms. Maier’s bus] was out of control because she put it in that condition” by driving too fast during horseplay, not because of poor maintenance, Judge Manning said.

But the judge found the condition of the bus contributed to the crash and found her not guilty of a summary offense related to the crash.

Mr. Frauens’ decision to leave without reporting the incident was “tantamount to admission” of his involvement in the crash, the judge said, but it didn’t rise to a felony because the other driver told him she would report it. His attorney, Bruce Carsia, said he was “very pleased” his client wasn’t convicted of the felony.

Advertise with us

Mr. Frauens said he was relieved by the verdict because his life had been “a nightmare every day” since the incident.

The judge also found the drivers not guilty of recklessly endangering four other motorists because they were too far away from the buses. He said he might have ruled differently if the bus drivers had been charged with endangering each other.

Attorney Joel Sansone, representing Ms. Maier, said she will continue her lawsuit against Port Authority claiming she was fired for reporting the poor condition of the bus after the crash.

“[The judge] certainly agreed the bus had problems,” Mr. Sansone said, adding he believes the Port Authority police charged the drivers to hide poor bus maintenance.

Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1470.