A fired Pittsburgh police sergeant won a partial victory when a district judge dropped the most serious criminal charge against him in connection with an arrest caught on video that showed him punching and shoving a drunk college student outside Heinz Field.

But Stephen Matakovich will still stand trial on other charges following a preliminary hearing Friday that marked the second go-round of the case against him.

Without providing an explanation, District Judge Dennis Joyce tossed a felony perjury charge against Mr. Matakovich along with counts of official oppression and unsworn falsification — the same charges tacked on by prosecutors in February when they refiled the case after a different district judge dismissed it.

The two original charges — simple assault and official oppression — were held for trial.

Advertise with us

Mr. Matakovich was expressionless as District Judge Joyce announced his decision, capping a three-hour-plus hearing. It was consistent with his demeanor throughout the proceeding. He declined to make any public comment though he occasionally whispered to his defense team, led by Blaine Jones.

Mr. Jones said his client was hoping for a complete dismissal, as was the case Feb. 1 when District Judge Robert Ravenstahl dismissed the case against the 22-year veteran.

Mike Manko, a spokesman for the Allegheny County District Attorney’s office, had no comment on Friday’s proceeding.

Mr. Matakovich, 47, of Brookline, also faces a two-count federal indictment for deprivation of civil rights and falsification of a record. He is to appear at the federal courthouse Downtown for arraignment April 26.

The former officer initially was suspended with pay in mid-December following the Nov. 28 incident that occurred at Heinz Field during the WPIAL playoffs. He was fired last month.

Advertise with us

Stadium security camera footage played in court Friday showed Mr. Matakovich pushing Gabriel Despres, then 19, with two hands and striking him several times. A mug shot taken that night of Mr. Despres, who was arrested following the incident and spent the night in the Allegheny County Jail, was shown in court. He had a swollen and bruised nose. Mr. Despres said he is a student at Penn State University, Behrend, in Erie, majoring in chemical engineering technology.

During testimony Friday, Mr. Despres said he doesn’t remember all of what happened that evening either because he had been “drinking too much or from being hit in the head.”

An attorney who is representing him in an expected civil case, Christopher Lepore, was in court Friday. He declined to comment, as did Mr. Despres.

Judge Joyce did not explain the reason for dismissing the charges. Mr. Jones argued that the case simply hadn’t been made.

Assistant District Attorney Jonathan Fodi countered that two acts of official oppression were committed, the first when Mr. Matakovich assaulted Mr. Despres and the second when he unduly arrested him. The perjury allegedly was committed during the first preliminary hearing when Mr. Matakovich testified in a way contrary to other witnesses regarding an allegation that he was — according to police paperwork — going to “put my foot up your [butt]” if Mr. Despres didn’t leave Heinz Field; and the unsworn falsification stemmed from Mr. Matakovich not disclosing on a police report that video of the incident existed.

Advertise with us

Testimony presented at the two preliminary hearings has painted an incident that began with Mr. Despres being heavily intoxicated and refusing numerous orders from several security officers as well as Mr. Matakovich to leave the Heinz Field property that evening.

Mr. Jones’ defense, as revealed in his cross-examination of five witnesses, will apparently hinge on his client’s perception of his own safety: that Mr. Despres was so drunk as to have been unpredictable, uncooperative and potentially dangerous. Mr. Jones argued at the close of the hearing that his client essentially was defending himself.

Karen Kane: kkane@post-gazette.com or at 724-772-9180.