Making good on a pledge from earlier this month, the Allegheny County District Attorney’s office refiled charges Friday against a Pittsburgh police sergeant accused of punching an intoxicated fan at Heinz Field and added two others, including lying under oath.
Stephen Matakovich, 47, of Brookline was charged via summons with perjury, a felony, submitting a false report and the original charges of official oppression and simple assault. Three witnesses uniformly reported that the fan was never aggressive and did not make a fist before the sergeant shoved him, knocking him to the ground on Nov. 28, city police Lt. Victor Joseph wrote in an affidavit filed Friday.
The sergeant’s attorney, Blaine Jones, said he had not seen the affidavit detailing the new charges but “was aware of the possibility” of prosecutors refiling the initial ones, which District Judge Robert Ravenstahl dismissed at a preliminary hearing Feb. 1
“We never stop preparing the case. We will be ready,” he said.
A spokesman for Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto said he supports the DA’s decision and that of city police Chief Cameron McLay to fire Sgt. Matakovich. The sergeant appealed the termination and is awaiting a final ruling from city public safety director Wendell Hissrich.
Security camera footage from Heinz Field shows Sgt. Matakovich push 20-year-old Gabriel Despres, of South Park, to the ground with two hands, then strike him several times. Mr. Despres, who was trying to get into the stadium to watch a high school football game after he drank heavily, was treated at a hospital for a bloody, swollen nose before spending the night in the Allegheny County Jail.
Read More
Sgt. Matakovich wrote in charging documents, and testified at the Feb. 1 preliminary hearing, that he had to take action because Mr. Despres took an aggressive stance and made a fist. But according to the new affidavit, the three witnesses — including two Landmark Event Staffing Services supervisors — told investigators that Mr. Despres had no such posture and kept his hands in his pockets.
Two of those witnesses recalled the sergeant saying something to the effect of, “If you don’t get out of here, I’m going to put my foot up your [butt],” Lt. Joseph wrote in the affidavit. Sgt. Matakovich testified during the Feb. 1 hearing that he said, “Listen, you just got to get out of here. Nobody is trying to put a foot up your [butt].”
One of the witnesses told the lieutenant that the statement was “a direct threat, he was trying to intimidate the guy to leave.” Even when Mr. Despres was told to leave and argued to get into the game, he was ”not aggressive or threatening, and he just kind of stood there,” the witness reported.
When Mr. Despres was told to leave, he began to walk away, one of the three witnesses told police. Sgt. Matakovich then said, “You’re not in Butler County, you’re in the big city,” and Mr. Despres — “drunk” and “just not getting it” — turned around with a, “What are you talking about?” look before the sergeant pushed him, according to the affidavit.
A preliminary hearing for Sgt. Matakovich is set for April 15. The district judge will be chosen from a rotating pool of 46, and if District Judge Ravenstahl happens to be reassigned to the proceeding, the DA’s office could ask for his recusal or petition Common Pleas Court President Judge Jeffrey A. Manning for a new judge.
Mr. Despres faces a preliminary hearing March 16 on summary charges of defiant trespass, public drunkenness and underage drinking stemming from the incident.
Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1944 or on Twitter @molly_born. Jonathan D. Silver contributed.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.