Prosecutors say a September 2014 bus accident on Interstate 279 occurred when two bus drivers were jockeying for position during a race and their vehicles collided, causing one bus to swerve out of control, through a guard rail and down a hill, where it landed on its side on Evergreen Road.
Drivers Juliann Maier, 47, of Ross and Thomas Frauens, 57, of Brookline face multiple charges including reckless endangerment and reckless driving in the non-jury trial that began Monday before Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey Manning. Mr. Frauens faces additional charges for not reporting the accident.
But defense attorneys paint a very different picture.
Joel Sansone, who represents Ms. Maier, said in his opening statement that he will present experts who will testify her bus was in such bad condition — including having brakes that were installed incorrectly — that it wouldn’t have passed inspection.
Bruce Carsia, representing Mr. Frauens, said his client was unaware the buses had collided and left the scene to begin his route only after he saw others approaching the crash and heard sirens from emergency vehicles coming to the scene. He later responded to a Port Authority radio call for anyone who had seen the accident by telephoning a road supervisor and told him he wasn’t involved but had seen the crash.
In his opening, Assistant District Attorney Brian Catanzarite said testimony will show that shortly after the buses left the Ross garage and were traveling side by side, Mr. Frauens made a “whipping motion” at his colleague to indicate he was going faster and later waved at her to encourage her to catch up to him.
Read More
As a result of the crash, Ms. Maier had multiple injuries, including a broken pelvis and four broken ribs. Mr. Sansone said she will testify about her safe driving record, the condition of the bus and her unsuccessful attempt to bring it under control.
“Nobody in their right mind plays tag with a bus,” Mr. Sansone said in his opening. “She was trying to control a bus that was out of control [due to mechanical problems].”
He claims that six months earlier another driver using the same bus went on worker’s compensation after she was injured trying to bring the bus back under control in another incident.
In an interview during a break in testimony, Mr. Sansone said Ms. Maier was “taking the fall for whoever left this bus on the road.”
Ms. Maier has filed a lawsuit challenging Port Authority’s decision to fire her, claiming she was dismissed for filing a report after the crash about the poor condition of her bus. Mr. Frauens also was fired.
During first-day testimony, several drivers testified who were either in front of or behind the buses just before the crash.
Karen Marchetti testified she was traveling behind the buses when each began swaying left and right. She said she kept her distance because “it didn’t look safe” and a few seconds later, the bus in the right lane struck the bus in the left lane, then swerved right and went over the hill.
Stuart Benson told the court he was in the right lane when he approached the buses and noticed them jockeying for position as they were side by side in front of him. When the bus in the right lane swerved, he first moved to the left lane and when it happened again he pulled off the left berm to stop.
“I was concerned there might be a safety issue,” he said. ”I didn’t know what was going to happen and I wanted to get as far away as I could.”
Moments later, he saw one bus go over the hill in a “large cloud of dust” and the other pull off on the right side. He went across the highway and he saw the injured driver crawl out of the passenger door and the other driver get out of his bus to survey the scene, he testified.
Prosecutors played several videos from Mr. Frauens’ bus and the bus garage to show the accident and the lack of damage when his bus left the garage. Former Port Authority police officer Shawn Granger said there was damage to the right rear panel and a broken window on Mr. Frauens’ bus when he inspected it on the South Side shortly after the incident.
The trial is expected to last more than a week.
Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1470.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.