A fired Port Authority bus driver on trial on charges that he was racing on Interstate 279 with a colleague who crashed over a hillside testified Wednesday that he could “see the fear on her face” because her bus was out of control.

In his first public statement about the September 2014 incident, Thomas Frauens, 57, of Brookline denied a prosecutor’s contention that the drivers were racing and jockeying for position. Mr. Frauens and Juliann Maier, 47, of Ross face multiple charges including reckless endangerment and reckless driving in a non-jury trial that began Monday before Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey Manning. Mr. Frauens faces an additional charge of leaving the scene of an accident.

Mr. Frauens, testifying on his own behalf, said he left the Port Authority’s Ross garage immediately behind Ms. Maier’s bus and started to pass her once they got on the highway because he had farther to go before beginning his route on the South Side compared to hers on the North Side. As he got beside her, he said, he noticed her bus “drifting a little” toward him once and then two more times, startling him.

“I could see the fear on her face that she didn’t have control of that bus,” he said under questioning by his attorney, Bruce Carsia.

Advertise with us

“I’m getting away from her at that point,” he said, describing how he steered his bus toward the left median to put space between the two vehicles. When he looked into his rear-view mirror, he said, “All of a sudden her bus careened to the right and over the hill.”

Mr. Frauens broke into tears on the stand as he described how he then pulled his bus off the right side a few hundred yards down the road. He ran back to the area where the other bus left the highway and saw Ms. Maier lying on the road outside her bus with many people attending to her.

When he first got to the scene, Mr. Frauens said, fellow driver April Crawl was there. She left first and said she would report the incident to Port Authority traffic control, Mr. Frauens said, so when he left a few minutes later he thought there was no reason to report the incident.

Although several prosecution witnesses testified that Ms. Maier crashed after the rear of her bus hit Mr. Frauens’ bus and that there was damage to the rear side panel and side window of his bus, he said he didn’t feel or hear any impact. He described himself as “distraught” but since he didn’t believe he was involved in the accident, he said, he had no reason to report it or stay at the scene.

“I had a route to do. That’s what I was going to do,” he said.

Advertise with us

Under questioning from Ms. Maier’s attorney, Joel Sansone, Mr. Frauens said the initial wave he gave Ms. Maier leaving the garage was a courtesy that drivers regularly show each other. A later motion that Mr. Frauens described as a “horse-racing whip” was just an indication for Ms. Maier to proceed to her route.

“I wasn’t inviting Julie to race with me or anything,” he said, adding that, “I can’t see Julie taking that” as an invitation to race.

In earlier testimony Wednesday, Ms. Crawl described Mr. Frauens running toward her as she looked over the hill at Ms. Maier’s bus, which end up on its side on Evergreen Road. Ms. Maier suffered a broken pelvis, four broken ribs and other injuries.

“He said he was passing Julie and Julie waved at him and then Julie went off the road,” she said.

Ms. Crawl said she has long been wary of the particular series of the bus that Ms. Maier was driving, saying she uses her seniority to select routes where that type of bus isn’t used. That seemed to support Mr. Sansone’s claim that the bus had a troubled history and experienced a mechanical failure that caused the crash.

Advertise with us

Ms. Maier has filed a lawsuit against Port Authority, claiming she was fired for reporting the mechanical issue after the crash.

“I don’t like them. They’re not, in my opinion, stable buses,” Ms. Crawl said. “I try to avoid [driving] them. If you hit something, they can very easily get away from you.”

Before the prosecution ended its case earlier Wednesday, Assistant District Attorney Brian Catanzarite presented testimony from a forensic paint analyst with the county medical examiner who said paint similar to Ms. Maier’s bus was found on the rear side panel of Mr. Frauens’ bus.

Ms. Maier is expected to testify when the trial resumes today.

Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1470.