The brakes and steering system of a Port Authority bus that crashed in September 2014 were so poor that the bus shouldn’t have been on the road and the driver would have had a difficult time controlling it, two mechanical experts testified Monday.

The experts said the bus driven by Juliann Maier, 47, of Ross had four mechanical problems with its brakes and steering, each of which was serious enough to prevent it from passing state inspection: mismatched brake components, a leaking brake line, a leaking air brake chamber and a severely worn stabilizing bar.

Prosecutors say Ms. Maier and another former driver, Thomas Frauens, 57, of Brookline, were racing on Interstate 279 just after they left the Ross garage Sept. 14, 2014, to begin their afternoon shift. They claim Ms. Maier’s bus ran off the road after the buses bumped while they were jockeying for position.

The drivers, who were fired, face multiple charges, including reckless endangerment and reckless driving in a nonjury trial before Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey Manning. Closing arguments are scheduled for this morning.

Advertise with us

Mr. Frauens also is accused of leaving the scene of an accident. He claims he wasn’t aware the buses collided and another driver told him that she would report Ms. Maier’s crash.

Ms. Maier’s attorneys claim the bus was in such poor mechanical condition that she was unable to control it, causing it to veer off the highway and roll down a hill onto Evergreen Road. She suffered a broken pelvis and four broken ribs, among other injuries.

The mechanical experts were the final witnesses called on behalf of Ms. Maier.

Robert A. Nocivelli, a forensic mechanic who has testified in hundreds of cases for the prosecution and defense, said he found the four safety problems as well as other questionable maintenance of the bus during more than 14 hours of examination. He cited additional problems including using motor oil in place of power steering fluid; metal fragments in the steering column that showed extreme wear of metal parts; a brake pedal that wobbled so far out of place that the driver may have hit the gas by mistake; and many parts of the steering column lacking needed lubrication.

The mismatched brake components were a particular problem, Mr. Nocivelli said, because they would have caused the bus to pull in one direction and then in the other in a way that would be difficult for the driver to overcome.

Advertise with us

“It’s just something you absolutely can’t have,” he said. “All of the manuals say … you never mismatch [brake components].”

As a result of all of those conditions, Mr. Nocivelli said, “driver Maier would have had a real problem maintaining control of this bus,” adding it would have been “very difficult if not impossible” to prevent the accident.

The other expert, Donald Kosker, testified he attended the same bus inspections and agreed that none of the mechanical problems occurred as a result of the crash. He teaches vehicle mechanics at Forbes Road Career and Technology Center in Monroeville and is a state-certified vehicle inspector.

As a result of the mechanical problems he found, Mr. Kosker said the bus “was not able to brake and steer adequately.”

“This bus should have been in a maintenance garage having repairs on it before it went out on the road,” he said.

Ed Blazina: eblazina@post-gazette.com