Nearly 25 years have passed since Carol Ramsey left heroin, cocaine, booze, theft, halfway houses, rehab programs, prison and broken promises behind her.
She insists that she’s no longer the person depicted in the yellowing court records, the woman who repeatedly shoplifted clothing to support her drug habit, attempted to obtain a narcotic with a forged prescription, got her hands on stolen U.S. government checks, violated probation, escaped from a constable’s car and overdosed while away from a step-down facility.
Some of the stores she stole from — G.C. Murphy, Hills and Woolworth’s — long ago disappeared. At 64, the soft-spoken Ms. Ramsey would like her record to vanish, too, so she can move into subsidized senior housing and get a part-time job working with children or the elderly.
For five years, students at Duquesne University School of Law have been working to obtain a pardon for Ms. Ramsey. In January, the state Board of Pardons unanimously recommended approval of Ms. Ramsey’s request. Now, her fate rests with Gov. Tom Wolf, who can make a decision at any time.
A pardon would forgive the Hill District resident’s offenses and enable her student attorneys to seek a court order expunging, or wiping clean, her record. Her checkered past would disappear from public view, removing barriers to housing and employment and giving her the satisfaction she craves.
“I’ve done my time. I’ve paid my fines, my costs. I’m a productive member of society. I believe I deserve a pardon,” said Ms. Ramsey, who works as a mentor at the Pennsylvania Organization for Women in Early Recovery in Point Breeze and is on the board of the Message Carriers recovery group in East Liberty.
Supporting her pardon application is Allegheny Common Pleas Senior Judge Judith Friedman, who presided at Ms. Ramsey’s last criminal case in 1992. “She believed in me,” Ms. Ramsey said.
Ms. Ramsey’s story cuts to the heart of a debate over social justice. How can offenders be rehabilitated when they are denied employment and housing? How long must they spend proving themselves? Which offenses should be forgiven?
The debate has spurred “ban-the-box” movements to keep ex-offenders from having to check boxes disclosing a criminal record on employment applications. It has led some cities, including Pittsburgh, to decriminalize possession of small amounts of marijuana. It led the law school’s Civil Rights Clinic to begin offering pardon and expungement services at its Uptown offices and in other locations. It prompted Mr. Wolf last month to sign legislation, sponsored by Sen. Stewart Greenleaf, R-Montgomery County, allowing certain misdemeanors to be shielded from public view without expungement so that former offenders have easier access to jobs and housing.
“If you are able to get your constituents back to work, or to work for the first time, it’s just something that benefits the commonwealth for everyone,” said Tracey McCants Lewis, the assistant clinical professor overseeing Ms. Ramsey’s case and those of about 75 other clients.
Ms. Ramsey has a kindred spirit in Corry Sanders, 45, who won an election for McKeesport City Council but was barred from taking the seat this year because of a 1993 no-contest plea to felony drug charges. The state constitution prohibits felons from holding office, even those such as Mr. Sanders who maintain they’ve accomplished a turnaround.
In a 1989 report, a court investigator working on one of Ms. Ramsey’s cases wrote that she had a “poor prognosis for the future” because of her pattern of crimes and other experiences. But Ms. Ramsey beat the odds, and she said others do, too.
“We can and do recover,” said Ms. Ramsey, who has a passel of misdemeanors and a couple of third-class felonies on her record. “We’re not just bums on the street.”
Much to overcome
Court records show how much Ms. Ramsey has overcome:
Her mother, Elsie, had seven children. But she is the only child from her mother’s relationship with her father, Carl, who had no daily role in her childhood. She left the city’s Fifth Avenue High School in the ninth grade but eventually received a General Education Development certificate. When Elsie died in 1975, Ms. Ramsey, the eldest, looked after her siblings because her mother’s husband didn’t know how to run a household.
Ms. Ramsey was married to Marion “Cisco” Lewis, a co-defendant in some of her cases, and became pregnant with twins while both were in drug rehab. A daughter and a son were born in 1981, but the latter lived only four days because of a bowel problem. Lewis died in 2009.
Ms. Ramsey had a “few short-lived barmaid jobs,” lost her job at a balloon-making company because she couldn’t keep up with the pace of work and got by with public assistance checks. She began abusing drugs at 21 and by the 1980s, an investigator wrote, she had “been through the gamut of drug programs.”
In an interview, Ms. Ramsey attributed her bad choices to her disadvantaged upbringing. ”When you know better, you do better.”
The breakthrough came in 1992, after Ms. Ramsey had racked up 12 criminal cases over 14 years. Presiding at one of Ms. Ramsey’s hearings, Judge Friedman ordered her into a 12-step program.
“That was the best thing that could ever happen to me, and I thank her often,” Ms. Ramsey said.
This time, she resolved to get clean and live honestly. Her daughter was growing up, and Ms. Ramsey wanted to be part of her life. ”I was tired of seeing the pain in her eyes. ... I guess I was just at that point in my life.”
‘Picture of rehabilitation’
In 2011, about 19 years into her sobriety, Ms. Ramsey took some of the recovering women she was mentoring to the Urban League of Greater Pittsburgh, where student attorneys from the Civil Rights Clinic regularly counsel clients about pardons, expungements and other legal issues. She decided that the clinic could help her, too.
Ms. Ramsey, who lives in an apartment owned by a sympathetic landlord, had been rejected for other housing because of her record. She feared that her past also would keep her from moving into government-run subsidized senior housing when she turned 65 and from working part time with the elderly or children during her retirement. So she became the clinic’s first candidate for a pardon, even though that meant reliving sad days, answering intrusive questions and repeatedly asserting her remorse.
Because of a backlog of requests, the pardon process takes years. The students who filed the application for Ms. Ramsey in 2012 now are well into their legal careers, but others have picked up the case.
“She’s the picture of rehabilitation,” said Jacqueline Russel, one of those now representing her.
At the recommendation of its investigator, who visited Pittsburgh to review the case, the Board of Pardons granted Ms. Ramsey a hearing in January. In preparation, the student attorneys grilled her at mock proceedings, videotaped the sessions and critiqued her performance.
The students said Ms. Ramsey, who had to represent herself at the hearing, presented her case so thoroughly that the board asked no questions. Ms. Ramsey is hopeful. Of the 112 pardons the board recommended last year, Mr. Wolf approved 107.
Years after a court investigator downplayed Ms. Ramsey’s “prognosis,” her student attorneys describe her as a success story and a role model for others seeking redemption.
“I find her very inspiring,” Ms. Russel said.
Joe Smydo: jsmydo@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1548






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.