For a group of congregants and preservationists looking to spare the nearly 110-year-old Albright United Methodist Church in Bloomfield from demolition, October brought mixed results.
On the one hand, the city’s Zoning Board of Adjustment denied a request Thursday for a special exception for a drive-through from Ross Development, which is proposing to put a coffee shop, possibly a Starbucks, on the site of the Romanesque and Gothic Revival stone church.
On the other: The city’s Historic Review Commission did not accept an application seeking to nominate the site as a historic landmark.
While other buildings can be nominated by anyone without the owner’s consent, “nominations of religious structures shall only be made by the owner of record,” Historic Preservation Planner Sarah Quinn wrote in a letter earlier this month to Taafoi Kamara, a member of the church’s congregation who filed the application.
Though the congregation, which describes itself as one of the oldest in the city, has made a claim of ownership to the church, a deed was filed in September with the Allegheny County Recorder of Deeds establishing the Western Pennsylvania Annual Conference of the United Methodist Church, made up of about 800 local churches in 23 counties, as the owner of record.
“We’re still encouraged. We always knew this was going to be a long process,” said Ms. Kamara, a health system administrator at UPMC who, along with her brother, Abass Kamara, was baptized in the church. It was also where their parents met and were married and where their mother’s funeral took place. “There are still a lot of avenues with historic preservation that we’re still going to pursue.”
The church was named to the Young Preservationists Association of Pittsburgh’s Top 10 Best Preservation Opportunities at an event Tuesday night at the Union Project in East Liberty, a nonprofit housed in a former church that Ms. Kamara sees as a model for what Albright could become.
“The thing we need to remember with historic buildings such as Albright church is when they’re gone, they’re gone,” said Matthew Craig, the Young Preservationists Association executive director.
The Western Pennsylvania Conference referred a reporter to its lawyer, David Barton, who said last month that the church hadn’t been used as a place of worship since November 2013 and the conference made a “determination of abandonment” in January, vesting ownership with the conference.
“This happens from time to time,” he said. “Often times churches no longer serve the religious mission.”
Anthony Ross, owner of Ross Development, said his real estate development firm has an “ironclad” agreement with the conference to buy and redevelop the site.
“They investigated adaptive reuse and they determined that it really couldn’t be done,” he said, citing issues with mold, water damage and flooding in the building. “If you walk through it, unfortunately it’s in pretty poor shape.”
Mr. Ross said he intends to appeal the zoning board’s decision.
“We’re going to do a retail project on the site. It’s zoned for it,” he said.
Robert Zullo: rzullo@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3909. Twitter: @rczullo.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.