The former Monessen Savings & Trust at 500 Donner Ave. will end its 110th year with plastic blowing like tattered flags from open windows, loose plywood on the ones that are covered and scraggly foliage waving from the balconies.
A demolition notice in the window of one of the last grand buildings in this Monongahela River city is not deterring Matthew Shorraw. The 24-year-old part-time band director and native son has a vision of its future.
He will have a huge task turning the Beaux Arts-style building into a music and arts center, starting with $70,000 in liens. He wants to get the liens waived, buy the building from the city and begin amassing investors. He has already submitted his plan, the 500 Donner Project, to foundations for grants.
After crunching the numbers as best he can, he figures a renovation would cost about $8 million.
Preservation is challenge enough in Pittsburgh, but in small cities such as Monessen, down from a population high of 28,000 before 1940 to 7,700 today, so many historic bones that could be building blocks for the future are crumbling, taking evidence of a strong past with them.
Placing the savings and trust on its 2015 Top Ten list of places ripe for intervention, the Young Preservationists Association of Pittsburgh noted that many towns and cities consider demolition as the first option to reduce blight.
Read More
Monessen Mayor Lou Mavrakis agrees with that option. He said there is too much blight to attract the kind of money the city needs to rebuild.
“Monessen has more blighted buildings downtown than all the third-class cities in Westmoreland County combined,” he said, describing the savings and trust as “25 years of pigeon [expletive] and a basement full of water. These people who say, ‘Oh, we’re going to save this grand structure,’ have fancy ideas and no money.”
He said if the entire block was leveled, a developer might be attracted, “but no one will want to invest with all that damn blight.”
Mr. Shorraw said demolition is the easy way.
“Some people see broken windows and say” — flicking his hand — “ ‘Just tear it down.’ But for the amount you need to tear it down, you could board the windows and work toward a new use. We will never build that kind of building again.”
Throughout the region, the odds are stacked against champions of preservation to buy or maintain historic properties.
In Wilmerding, the all-volunteer nonprofit Wilmerding Renewed Inc. gave up after nine years operating the George Westinghouse Castle at 325 Commerce St. The building is scheduled for auction in Allegheny County’s Jan. 4 sheriff’s sale.
The group gave tours of the 59 rooms to raise money to pay bills, as much as $10,000 a month just for heating. The members took turns keeping grass and hedges cut and got an intern to create a Facebook page.
Insurance paid for repairs when a toilet flooded an upper floor, but, finally, “we conceded we could not make it,” said Geraldine Homitz, a volunteer for Wilmerding Renewed and a former mayor. The tours ended this fall.
“That castle means a lot” to Wilmerding, she said. “It’s too important to be boarded up.”
The local, state and federal landmark was built in the 1890s as headquarters of the Westinghouse Air Brake Co. Its transformation, by some estimates, and depending on future use, would cost about $10 million.
In Pittsburgh, possibly the most vulnerable is the West End’s Old Stone Tavern. Ledgers suggest it might have been built in 1756, but it could have replaced the original, still probably in the 18th century.
Since 2009, Harris Masonry, an adjacent business, has owned it.
“They have been cooperative about letting us go in,” said Noreen Beatty, a member of the Pittsburgh Old Stone Tavern Friends Trust. Their goal is to buy it, but sale of the tavern would include sale of the rest of the Harris lot.
At roughly $1 million, “it’s almost insurmountable,” she said. “We’ve been trying to find people interested in the warehouse and other pieces of Harris’ property, such as for a brewery or other large venture.
“I’ve been speaking to the DAR [Daughters of the American Revolution] and other historic groups about the people who were in that tavern making history — 66 veterans of the American Revolution; 72 who took part in the Whiskey Rebellion — both sides — and 16 who fought in the War of 1812.
“We’re grabbing for anything. We need a guy on a white horse to come in. But time is of the essence.”
On a recent blustery day in the heart of Monessen, Mr. Shorraw pointed out the remaining buildings from Monessen’s heydays.
“They build ugly on the outskirts, but here there is so much history,” he said. “Every corner used to have buildings like this.” The ones that remain “are opportunities.”
“Matt could help us if we gave him the tools,” said John Scott Nestor, a first-term city councilman. “Some people want to see things demolished, but what is our plan after that? What are our goals as a collective whole?”
Across from the savings and trust, Mr. Shorraw noted a long row of original three- and four-story buildings, most from the turn of the 20th century.
“They’re the last contiguous original buildings in town, but that won’t be true in a few weeks,” he said. “Malec’s [an old cabinetry shop made of stone, with iron balconies] is being torn down because it’s caving in in back.”
Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1626.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.