For the second year in a row, the Young Preservationists Association of Pittsburgh included a pedestrian walkway on its Top 10 list of historic structures.
A steel footbridge on Wilksboro Avenue in Brighton Heights, built in 1890, connected two stubs of the avenue between California and Termon avenues. Now those stubs are dead ends. The footbridge was barricaded in 2007. Its slender, pale blue supports, pied by rust, extend into an 86-foot ravine.
By listing nontraditional sites, the association expands its scope of interest beyond buildings. Last year, a footbridge that had already been demolished — across Norfolk Southern tracks in Allegheny Commons Park on the North Side — made the list as a symbol of the social cost of losing historic structures, however small they may seem.
The city has no structure like the 400-foot-long Wilksboro Avenue bridge. City Councilwoman Darlene Harris said $420,000 has been collected to restore it, though the project will probably cost $800,000 or more.
The preservation group also gave a nod to the city by putting our iconic public steps on the list, though none in particular.
“That was our way of saying thank you,” said Matthew Craig, the association’s executive director. The city is exploring the possibility of historic designations for some steps.
Read More
The Smithfield Street building that contained Downtown’s former Frank & Seder Department Store — across from the former Macy’s, nee Kaufmann’s — is the group’s No. 1 choice for rescue from possibly being demolished for a modern skyscraper.
Oxford Development owns the six-story, circa 1918 building.
“We’re trying to encourage [Oxford] to think about how repurposing it could be to great benefit,” Mr. Craig said. “Someone with insight and vision could make that a gem.”
The challenges of preserving older buildings will continue to grow, given the renovation costs per square foot vis-a-vis what a developer has to charge tenants to make money on its investment.
Serendipity might bless a historic property if a developer includes it in a larger project. The ARC House — originally a German bank on East Ohio Street in the North Side’s East Deutschtown — will be restored for use beside a new hotel, retail and housing complex that October Development expects to begin building in the spring.
Historic preservation otherwise needs altruists with deep pockets, nonprofit backing, social media campaigns, the public trough or a combination of these.
The city of Monessen owns the Monessen Savings and Trust, a 1905 Beaux Arts gem that Matthew Shorraw, an assistant band director at Monessen High School, nominated for preservation. He hopes to buy it and create an arts destination as an anchor for the struggling town.
It has been vacant for about 30 years, and, although it is blighted, he said, “it’s actually in pretty good shape, framed in steel and covered in brick and stone. I grew up here and have always loved that building. It’s beautiful. We have lost so many already, and few are that old.”
Katie Nolan, a fourth-generation Mount Washington resident, nominated 520 Grandview Ave. to call attention to one of the neighborhood’s last Queen Anne-style homes.
“It has been on the market a long time and shows a little disrepair, but it’s an iconic house,” she said. “Older people remember it was the first in the neighborhood with an icebox. I couldn’t stand the thought that it could be torn down for a metal and glass condo. If someone would just buy it and turn it into a bed and breakfast ...”
The other sites on the Top 10 list are the Old Stone Tavern (circa 1782) in West End Village, the George Westinghouse Castle (1890) in Wilmerding, the Albright United Methodist Church (1905) in Bloomfield, the Elizabeth Moose Lodge (1880s) in Elizabeth and 212-214 Blvd. of the Allies (formerly Tramp’s and Papa J’s, 1860) in Downtown Pittsburgh.
Mr. Craig said the association will revisit the ghost footbridge in Allegheny Commons Park for a future list. The city has made sounds about replacing it when there is funding, but it’s easy to infer what that means — if funding should somehow appear.
Norfolk Southern wants to raise the height of its cargo, but for higher loads through the park on the sunken tracks, two vehicular bridges would have to be raised, and raising one seems to be a nonstarter for the city. So why not start assembling money to return the footbridge to the park?
If Wilksboro Avenue has a fund to regain its lost connection, there’s hope.
Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1626.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.