Federal prosecutors on Wednesday moved to permanently seize a yacht called “Players Club,” two luxury cars and more than $1 million from a Robinson woman they contend embezzled millions from North Shore-based Matthews International Corp.
In a forfeiture filing, the U.S. Attorney’s office said the IRS and U.S. postal inspectors have been investigating Cynthia Mills, 54, former treasury specialist for Matthews’ Bronze Division.
The investigation surfaced when Matthews said in its third-quarter financial report released July 30 that a former employee was suspected of stealing $14 million.
Ms. Mills, who goes by Cindy, was not identified at the time, but her lawyer has since identified her and acknowledged that she is the target of a federal investigation. She has not been charged.
The forfeiture filing is the first public document identifying Ms. Mills as a suspect.
Prosecutors said Ms. Mills was responsible for various financial transactions at Matthews, including initiating wire transfers to pay vendors, and moved embezzled funds into various bank accounts she maintained in her name and that of her husband, Gary Mills, who was also co-owner of the yacht and the cars.
Read More
Prosecutors said Ms. Mills bought the $645,000 yacht, two Mercedes and a Ford Focus with the stolen money and deposited some of the funds into an account at First National Bank in the name of Designs by Cindy, her personal business.
The motion for forfeiture said Ms. Mills embezzled nearly $4 million in 76 wire transfers between October 2013 and May 2015, but it also said the investigation has revealed that she had been embezzling from Matthews “in multiple ways” since 2003.
Prosecutors said the bank accounts have been frozen and the two Mercedes and the yacht have been seized and are being stored in Ohio.
If the $14 million that Matthews says it has lost through the scheme is accurate, the case would be one of the largest embezzlement prosecutions in Western Pennsylvania.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1504.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.