A former employee for North Shore-based Matthews International Corp. pleaded guilty Wednesday to embezzling close to $13 million from the company over 16 years.
Cynthia Mills, 56, of McKees Rocks, waived indictment by a federal grand jury and entered a plea agreement before U.S. District Judge Nora Barry Fischer in which she would serve 7 ½ years in federal prison, three years probation, forfeit assets she obtained with the embezzled funds and pay restitution to her former employer in the amount of $12,969,774.
The charges against her included mail fraud, wire fraud, tax evasion and theft, crimes that occurred between 1999 and May 2015 when she was responsible for depositing checks and recording transactions into the general ledger for Matthews International, a conglomerate best known for manufacturing funeral products.
She will be formally sentenced on July 28. Meanwhile she remains free on a $10,000 unsecured bond.
Ms. Mills, who was a cashier and treasury specialist, was able to siphon money from the company over a period of time by opening a bank account under the name of a fake company called Designs by Cindy, which she controlled.
Part of her responsibilities at Matthews involved depositing checks made payable to Matthews and handling wire transfers to pay vendors. Federal prosecutors said she moved funds into the bank account she controlled and took a number of steps to cover her tracks by altering Matthews’ bank statements and creating false invoices.
Read More
Prosecutors said Ms. Mills and her husband, Gary, used the stolen proceeds to live a lavish lifestyle. She purchased items such as high-end jewelry, furs, homes, a yacht and expensive cars. She and her husband also gambled.
Her husband had worked as a UPS driver, but was able to retire because the money from Matthews allowed the couple to be financially independent, according to prosecutors
Ms. Mills told the court she has been unemployed since leaving her job at Matthews and has been unable to find other employment due to the publicity from her embezzlement case, the largest on record in Western Pennsylvania.
As part of her plea deal, Ms. Mills has agreed to hire an auctioneer to auction off her primary residence on Falck Road, which she bought with her husband for $194,000 in 1997. The home is now valued at $245,800 for tax purposes.
She will also relinquish 50 percent of whatever income she receives in federal prison, and she must immediately notify the court of any improvement in her economic condition after leaving prison so that her restitution payments can be increased.
Tim Grant: tgrant@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1591.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.