A dispute over secrecy is the latest battleground in the ongoing court fight over how late billionaire publisher Richard Mellon Scaife used a $450 million trust to prop up the operations of the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review newspaper.

As Mr. Scaife’s children mount their legal challenge to how the trust was handled — to the Tribune-Review’s benefit and to their personal detriment, they allege — the brother and sister are seeking records to bolster their case that the trustees violated the terms of the trust.

In a court filing Tuesday in Allegheny County Orphans’ Court, David and Jennie Scaife’s attorneys accused the trustees of delaying the production of information by refusing to turn over certain records without a confidentiality or protective order — in other words, out of sight of the public and the media.

Petition to Overrule Objections to Discovery (PDF)

Advertise with us

Petition to Overrule Objections to Discovery (Text)

In their responses to the children’s information requests, the trustees — PNC Bank and attorneys H. Yale Gutnick and James M. Walton — cited various arguments for keeping the records shielded from the public, such as attorney-client privilege, the court filing claims.

But the Scaife children are asking Judge Kathleen A. Durkin to dismiss all the trustees’ arguments in favor of secrecy, and to order them to turn over the various records in full public view.

William Pietragallo II and James F. Mannion, the attorneys for the children, wrote that the trustees’ request for confidentiality is “unnecessary and inappropriate,” and they accused them of raising the issue as a delay.

Attorney David Strassburger, of Strassburger McKenna Gutnick & Gefsky, which represents Mr. Gutnick, declined to comment.

Advertise with us

The Scaife children contend that over a 20-year period, Mr. Gutnick, Mr. Walton and PNC Bank drained a fund, created in 1935 by Sarah Mellon Scaife, to subsidize the publisher’s newspaper instead of relying on Mr. Scaife’s “considerable personal wealth available to him to finance his hobby without raiding the 1935 Trust,” according to court filings.

The son and daughter, who were to receive any money remaining in the fund upon their father’s death, have argued that the distributions violated the terms of the trust by allowing it to run dry, and are seeking a nine-figure recovery. They have accused Mr. Gutnick of a conflict of interest, and said the trustees breached their fiduciary duties.

The trustees have maintained that spending on newspapers and philanthropy was consistent with the trust terms.

In light of the trustees’ desire to keep certain documents from public view, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reiterated its intent to keep the court fight’s twists and turns transparent.

“These proceedings involve significant issues of public importance and legal precedent,” Post-Gazette Executive Editor David M. Shribman said. “It was for this reason that the Post-Gazette, along with The Philadelphia Inquirer, sought and was granted the right to enforce the press’ right of access under the First Amendment. We will oppose any effort to have a confidentiality order entered that will impede that right.”

Advertise with us

The children’s attorneys have asked that the court address the issues Sept. 15.

Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.