They poured urine on him while he slept, put syrup and soap in his boots and left feces on his sheets and in his bedroom vent.

In the weeks before 16-year-old Nicholas Grant received the beating in January that ultimately killed him, he was subjected to various indignities by four fellow residents at the Carrick group home, according to a state inspection report that helped form the basis for revoking the license of the home operated by Circle C Youth and Family Services.

And when the vicious beating occurred, the state said, the single staff person on duty tried to break up the fight but did not follow policy because she “failed to implement a manual restraint technique.”

The state issued a letter on March 31, informing the agency that it was revoking the license for the home in Carrick. In the letter to Circle C executive director Richard C. Knouff, Matthew J. Jones, the director of the state Department of Human Services’ Bureau of Human Services Licensing, cited mistreatment or abuse of clients, gross incompetence, negligence or misconduct.

Advertise with us

A month later, Allegheny County informed Circle C it was severing all ties with the agency. In a letter dated April 29, the county notified the nonprofit that it would not renew its contract when it expires June 30. The county gave no reason.

As a result, the board of Circle C, which operates three other group homes, voted unanimously May 6 to shut down after 47 years. According to the latest Circle C annual report, its contract with the county accounted for 96 percent of its referrals. County officials said Circle C had received more than $1.7 million on its current contract.

“Based on that, we’re no longer financially feasible to continue to provide services,” Ed Shea, the board’s president, said Wednesday. “It was a very tough, very emotional board decision.”

Mr. Shea said he and other board members were trying to get to the bottom of the county’s decision. Asked whether he thought Nicholas’ death had anything to do with it, he said, “I’m sure that was part of their deliberation. How could it not be?”

Mark Bertolet, a spokesman for the county department of human services, would not explain the move.

Advertise with us

The Circle C board was taken by surprise.

“This was very sudden. It was not our expectation,” Mr. Shea said, adding that the board hoped that the situation would be resolved by closing only the Carrick Avenue home where Nicholas was beaten and being forbidden to accept short-term “shelter” residents.

“I believe what happened at Circle C could have happened at any other group home in the state. It’s just extremely unfortunate. There are altercations from time to time. Seldom do they end with a fatality or serious injury,” Mr. Shea said. “I just want the general public to know what we’ve done. I’m very proud of our staff. I’m proud of our board. There are many, many success stories behind Circle C Youth Services over our 47 years. That’s what we want our legacy to be, not one unfortunate incident.”

During five visits between January and March, state inspectors found numerous violations at the Carrick Avenue facility. One of the violations, while not naming Nicholas, describes the circumstances that preceded his beating Jan. 10 by two other residents.

Sometimes the teen fought back. He got into a scuffle with one of his assailants in December that resulted in treatment at the hospital. Nicholas threatened his tormentors. The next day he told a staff person that he was still being harassed and would defend himself with a pen.

Advertise with us

On Jan. 6, the day the feces were found on his sheets, toothpaste was discovered on Nicholas’ door and floor. Four days later, police said, Malik Crosby, 16, and Yusuf Shepard, 15, beat Nicholas with fists, feet and a vacuum cleaner — ultimately putting him in a choke hold. He died three days later.

The two are charged as adults with homicide, aggravated assault and criminal conspiracy, and have August hearings at which a judge will decide whether to move their cases down to juvenile court.

The Carrick facility shut down the day after Nicholas died, said Diana Fishlock, a state human services spokeswoman.

“If the Circle C system cannot keep them safe, then in my opinion it’s a good thing they have closed them down,” said Mary Bauer, the fiance of Nicholas’ father, Lee Grant Jr. “I don’t think the security was adequate to have one woman and [four] teenage boys in the home that can’t be controlled. She watched a young man die because of their system.”

Mr. Shea expressed sympathy for Nicholas’ family.

Advertise with us

“That being said, the two other individuals who are incarcerated, they can be considered victims, too,” Mr. Shea said. “It’s certainly not the outcome that any social service agency would find acceptable.”

As Circle C winds down its operations, its staff, which has dwindled from 45 workers, must find new employment. The county said five children remain in a Circle C group; they are in the process of being transferred.

Attorney Todd Hollis, who is representing Nicholas’ family, said he was thankful that the authorities investigated the facility. He said he had not heard about the previous incidents involving Nicholas until contacted by a reporter Wednesday.

“If that did, in fact, occur, then it makes Nicholas’ death … 10 times worse because the program clearly knew about the behavioral issues and did not adequately staff, train, monitor, supervise or put anything into effect that would have protected the unnamed child and Nicholas Grant,” he said.

Staff writer Liz Navratil contributed. Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.