Allegheny County Controller Chelsa Wagner and her challenger, Mark Patrick Flaherty, traded charges about politics and competence Thursday as they continued their acrimonious battle over who should lead the office they both have held.

In a joint interview with Post-Gazette editors, Ms. Wagner repeated her contention that rather than serving as a watchdog, Mr. Flaherty would be subservient to his ally and her political foe, county Executive Rich Fitzgerald.

Mr. Flaherty, who held the office for two terms, said the professionalism and standards of the office have eroded during his successor’s tenure.

Ms. Wagner is in the midst of a legal battle over whether she can audit several governmental authorities tied to county government. She contends the resistance reflects a lack of transparency that is shared by Mr. Fitzgerald.

Advertise with us

Mr. Flaherty, who noted that he had audited the Port Authority and the Sports and Exhibition Authority during his stint as controller, argued that the current impasse can be blamed on the politicization of the office under Ms. Wagner.

“Right now, the office is in crisis; it’s in turmoil,” he said.

In earlier skirmishes, Mr. Flaherty prevailed in endorsement votes by the Allegheny County Democratic Committee and the Allegheny County Labor Council.

Ms. Wagner attributed those setbacks to what she characterized as heavy-handed lobbying, and horse trading by Mr. Fitzgerald. She conceded that she could not prove her charges, contending that people who had told her about the supposed maneuvering feared political retribution.

While boasting of her record on labor issues, she claimed that several building trades unions had been promised favorable treatment by the county in return for their support of Mr. Flaherty.

Advertise with us

“His position is extremely compromised,” she said of her opponent, “... when you have someone whose strongest supporter is the county executive.”

Mr. Flaherty said such unsubstantiated charges demonstrated how Ms. Wagner had alienated other government officials.

“The fact that she would say something like that and not offer any proof ... that’s why she’s having problems,” he said.

Mr. Flaherty dismissed Ms. Wagner’s suggestion that, as a candidate, he was a pawn of Mr. Fitzgerald’s.

Mr. Flaherty said he had made thousands of calls wooing contributors and party supporters during his campaign.

He said she was disingenuous in questioning the results of the labor and county endorsements after losing them.