Allegheny County Controller Chelsa Wagner said she will ask the county Board of Elections to look into a late surge in membership of a local LGBT political advocacy group — and the money that changed hands with it — prior to the organization’s vote Sunday on candidate endorsements.
Ninety people submitted membership forms — and cash registration fees — to the Steel City Stonewall Democrats in the hours before a midnight Monday deadline, nearly doubling the group’s membership, according to Jim Sheppard, the organization’s president.
Ms. Wagner said Wednesday the list of new members is rife with county employees “acting at the direction of [County Executive] Rich Fitzgerald” in an attempt to win the group’s endorsement for Mark Patrick Flaherty, her opponent in the Democratic primary next month.
“This mirrors what goes on in county government, which is an attempt to monopolize and control every minute detail in a way that is really anti-democratic,” said Ms. Wagner, who has clashed with Mr. Fitzgerald on several occasions involving county finances. “Most importantly, in this instance you see a very clear paper trail in a bag of cash.”
Amie Downs, director of communications for the county, Wednesday night criticized Ms. Wagner for “embellishments and breaks from reality.”
“Let me be clear: The county executive has never forced, required or directed a county employee to participate in a organization, vote or other political activity; nor would he,” Ms. Downs said in an emailed statement. “I don't know the number of county employees who may or may not be members of the Steel City Stonewall Democrats, nor do I need to. What an employee or any other resident of this county does to exercise their First Amendment rights and participate in the political process has absolutely nothing to do with their jobs. I'm stunned that Chelsa, as an elected official, would take any stance that discourages such participation in our democracy.”
Read More
The money involved, according to Mike Mikus, amounts to $2,580 that came from his political action committee Better Jobs, Better Future and will be properly reflected in the group’s campaign finance report due in the coming weeks.
“We recruited people to join the Stonewall group so they would be able to vote on Sunday’s endorsement,” said Mr. Mikus, the PAC’s chairman.
“This has been going on with Democratic committee endorsements for years,” he said. “Chelsa did this four years ago. Her Uncle Jack [Wagner] did it two years ago. It’s an organizing tool. It gives you an opportunity as an organization to see where you are in terms of recruiting volunteers, getting people excited and getting people engaged. I think the biggest problem that Chelsa Wagner has right now is that her campaign has come up short on endorsements. ... I think it’s just sour grapes on her part.”
D.J. Ryan, membership director for Steel City Stonewall Democrats, said he and other board members accepted the new membership forms Monday evening. The fees were $15 for students, $35 for an individual and $50 for a couple.
“My goal is to get more members,” he said. “And these are longtime supporters of the LGBT community and they are good people. It adds some strong people to our ranks, so it’s a win-win for everybody. And, in the end, they’re going to vote the way they want.”
But Mr. Sheppard, who works for Ms. Wagner in the controller’s office, and fellow board member Levi Hahn thought the eleventh-hour wave of new members — and the fact that they all paid cash rather than by credit card or check — was inappropriate and tried to stop it. They were outvoted by a majority of the board, prompting Mr. Hahn to resign.
“Upon hearing of these actions and because I am committed to a free and fair election process, I put forward a motion to the board questioning the validity of these new memberships,” Mr. Hahn said in a statement. “It is my belief that these new members have joined neither in good faith nor have they joined for the purpose of furthering the mission of promoting LGBT equality within the Democratic Party. Their new member statuses instead have been the result of an effort to undermine the integrity of the endorsement in an effort to support a particular candidate.”
Mr. Sheppard said he hoped to organize a meeting of the board today “to try to clean up this entire mess.”
Ms. Wagner rejected the suggestion that everyone played by the rules and it’s just Allegheny County politics.
“I work on merit,” she said. “I would never in my life stoop to the tactics that they have done here or throughout this process. I will always operate my campaign with integrity. They get into the mud. I would never try to buy an election or any portion of an election. ... That’s not how I operate. It’s incredibly disingenuous. It’s pandering and patronizing. It’s what gives politics a bad name. I don’t pay people in exchange for an endorsement or to try to manipulate the process.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.