A Spring Hill woman who took a neighbor’s dog and had it euthanized was sentenced Friday to three to six months in jail after being sternly admonished by the judge, who said she showed “no remorse” and posed a danger to the community “because she believes she can do whatever she wants.”

Gisele Paris, 58, was found guilty in December of theft, receiving stolen property and cruelty to animals and had faced up to 10 years in jail for taking a Siberian husky that belonged to Mark Boehler, 55, in November 2013. She had the dog put down two months later.

“I don’t see anything to indicate that you understand the wrongfulness of your conduct,” Common Pleas Judge Anthony M. Mariani of Allegheny County told her during Friday’s sentencing hearing. “Your attitude is, ‘Judge, I wouldn’t do it again because I got in trouble, but what I did was right.’ ”

Ms. Paris also must serve two years’ probation and pay a $1,000 fine as well as court costs. Her attorney, Robert Mielnicki, indicated that he will file an appeal.

Advertise with us

Mr. Boehler, who attended the hearing, said he felt the sentence was “very appropriate.”

The 8-year-old dog at the center of the case, Thor, disappeared from Mr. Boehler’s fenced-in yard and was seen with Ms. Paris on numerous occasions.

During her trial, Ms. Paris claimed she found the dog in a vacant lot, cared for it and took it to Penn Animal Hospital in the Strip District because it had been neglected. After learning that it would cost more than $600 to remove growths on the dog’s hindquarters, Ms. Paris called a veterinarian in February 2014 to euthanize it in her home.

Saying that “the essence of the case was more about cruelty than theft,” Judge Mariani said he based his decision, in part, on statements Ms. Paris made in a letter to the court that was part of the presentence report. In the letter, Ms. Paris claimed that during the time she had the dog, Thor would frolic in the snow with her own dog and was as “playful as a pup.” Neighbors who saw the dog with her remarked upon how much better it looked, she said.

“She said the dog was healthy when she cared for it,” Judge Mariani said. “That was the dog she had euthanized.”

Advertise with us

During the trial, assistant district attorney Matthew Wholey said Ms. Paris had the dog put down because police had gone to her home searching for it. On Friday, Mr. Wholey criticized “the audacity and arrogance” of Ms. Paris.

“She has shown no remorse, no sympathy, no regret,” he said. “She had the chance to apologize to Mr. Boehler, and she said nothing.”

Mr. Boehler, who suffers from Stage 3 esophageal cancer and had a tumor the size of a tennis ball removed from his brain last month, used his opportunity to speak at the hearing to at times shout at Ms. Paris. Judge Mariani twice instructed him to address the court rather than Ms. Paris.

“All I wanted was my dog back,” Mr. Boehler said to Ms. Paris before starting to cry. “He was mine! Just because you stole him and killed him doesn’t make him yours.”

Barry Paris, a Pittsburgh Post-Gazette freelance writer who is Ms. Paris’ cousin, spoke on her behalf and criticized Mr. Boehler for his “theatrics.”

Advertise with us

“[Ms. Paris] is one of the most kind, gentle, animal-concerned people I’ve ever known,” Mr. Paris said while asking the judge to sentence her to probation, preferably doing community service with animals. “I think she was deeply confused. ... But there was no malice of any kind. Just the opposite.”

After seeing his cousin fighting back tears as she was taken from the courtroom in handcuffs to the Allegheny County Jail, Mr. Paris called the sentence “vicious, vindictive and inappropriate.”

It was Mr. Boehler, he said, who “should have been on trial for abuse and neglect of the animal. ... The problem was the maltreatment and abuse of the animal in the first place.”

Ms. Paris still faces two felony counts of aggravated assault and a count of resisting arrest related to the incident.