Cameron McLay thought his career as a police officer in Madison, Wis., was going to end as a rookie, when supervisors asked him whether he had ever cheated on a recruit exam.
The atmosphere in the classroom had become loose. Supervisors sometimes left the room. Some recruits exchanged answers and were later fired.
“I still remember the test question to this day because it was a fairly traumatic experience for me,” Mr. McLay, Pittsburgh’s acting police chief and nominee for the permanent position, said in a recent interview. He appeared before Pittsburgh City Council for a confirmation hearing Monday and a vote on his nomination could happen today.
The question was, “What is the department’s authorized ammunition?” He included all of the details except for the weight of the bullet, which he said someone mentioned to him when he stood up to turn in his paper.
“I had known that, but I didn’t write it, so I put it in there,” Mr. McLay said. “When asked ‘did I ever receive an answer?’ I said, ‘Yes, yes, I did.’ … I was not certain that I wasn’t going to get fired.”
It was the “only blemish in a 30-plus year career,” he said in a recent interview with the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
Read More
More than 140 pages of documents that the Madison police department released and interviews with former colleagues support that idea. His personnel file contained dozens of glowing recommendations and thanks from local residents and business owners who noted his response to burglaries, drug activity and killings, to name a few. Madison police investigated four additional complaints about Mr. McLay, all of which they labeled as “not sustained” or “unfounded.”
Regardless, the cheating scandal remains clear in his mind and, like other experiences during his 29 years working in Madison, will likely affect the way he manages the Pittsburgh department. Mr. McLay completed a 2.5-hour interview with City Council Monday afternoon. If approved at a vote today, he will succeed a former chief, Nate Harper, who is in federal prison on charges he conspired with others to steal from the bureau and failed to file income tax returns.
Mr. McLay was 26 years old, working as an officer at the Indiana University police department in Bloomington, Ind., when he submitted a four-page application to join the Madison police force.
He wrote of his experience as a Tae Kwon Do instructor and defense tactics coordinator. He noted that he had coordinated a fundraiser for the Special Olympics and wanted to change departments because of a “lack of promotion/career opportunities” in Indiana.
The written reprimand he received from the cheating scandal remains clear in his mind. Mr. McLay said it was “reflective of what a chief should tell a young officer who made a mistake and you made a determination that it wasn’t a character flaw but an otherwise good person who made a mistake.” He said he would likely act similarly faced with the same situation.
Mayoral spokesman Tim McNulty said Mr. McLay disclosed the episode several times during the hiring process. “Cam has an amazing 30-year resume in policing, and we’re overjoyed that he’s bringing [it] to Pittsburgh,” Mr. McNulty said.
The following years went more smoothly. Mr. McLay graduated from the Madison training program with a score of 94.29, about four points higher than the average in his class of 14 recruits.
His role in the Madison department grew, and so did his list of commendations, recommendations and thank-yous. Two years after he joined, the Madison chief wrote a letter thanking the young officer for his quick response to the theft of a $17,000 boat. By the early 1990s, he was helping to evaluate and field train new officers.
Those years were not completely without controversy.
In 1987, while still on patrol, the mother of a man he arrested filed a complaint about the force he used. Documents from the investigation indicate that Mr. McLay was dispatched to a report of a possible sexual assault in progress at a trailer. He was the first officer on the scene, and when he arrived he encountered a bloodied woman.
Mr. McLay ordered a man, whose name was redacted, to stay away from the woman, and when the man refused he ended up in a scuffle that ended with Mr. McLay tossing him out of the trailer, police wrote.
The woman who filed the complaint wrote that her son was administering aid to the injured woman when police arrived.
A lieutenant who investigated the call response wrote that Mr. McLay “found himself fighting to just maintain his own safety” when the man refused to comply and that the complaint should not be sustained.
“It was dangerous and it was scary, so at the end of the day, they’re evaluating what I did based on that context,” Mr. McLay said.
Investigations into Pittsburgh officers’ force will continue to be done using the same legal standards, Mr. McLay said, although there could be some slight modifications. Mr. McLay left open the possibility that he could work with the police union to increase the amount of information he can give to the public about officer discipline.
Shortly after he arrived, he banned the use of blackjacks, pieces of lead wrapped in leather and once used to hit suspects over the head. He called them “something of an anachronism in modern policing.”
“It doesn’t communicate the modern image that we’re hoping to communicate.”
Mr. McLay came here from Madison, which has a population of about 240,000. Some in law enforcement hail the Wisconsin city, and others mocked it.
Those who admire the city look to its history of community-oriented policing, which emphasizes building relationships with residents and community groups as a way to reduce crime. Others have called the officers tree-huggers, and current Madison police Chief Michael Koval joked that some others in the state refer to him as “Kumbaya Koval.”
Mr. McLay has already tried to incorporate some methods used in Wisconsin in Pittsburgh. Council members have questioned some of them, including efforts to eventually replace the deputy chief position with a civilian chief of staff. Others, such as the recent response to police protests and attendance at community meetings, have earned him praise.
When Monday’s council hearing ended, President Bruce Kraus told Mr. McLay, “I think you’ll probably sleep pretty well tonight.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.