MERRIMAC, Wis. – Cameron McLay applied for police chief positions three times before he retired as a captain from the Madison, Wis., police department this year.

He has enjoyed the months since then, spending much of his time traveling the country and teaching leadership courses to police supervisors through the International Association of Chiefs of Police.

“I actually didn’t think I wanted to be a chief,” he said, but a part of him missed the “organizational life” that comes with belonging to a bureau.

He learned that Pittsburgh was looking for a chief to lead a force that over the past year and a half had seen the indictment of its former leader, the suspension of several other officers and a federal investigation of its affairs.

Advertise with us

As he sat on the porch of his red house overlooking rolling green hills about an hour outside of Madison, he wondered what his wife, Debra, would think if he applied.

He mentioned it to her briefly. She had already seen that the city was hiring. “I think it could be really cool,” he recalled her saying.

Over the weeks that followed, Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto and Public Safety Director Stephen Bucar attended community meetings to hear what residents and officers wanted in the next chief. A search committee composed of community leaders, a professor and a former officer, among others, narrowed the pool to 10 finalists.

When Mr. Peduto called Mr. McLay on Monday to offer him the job, “It was really difficult, as exciting as it was, to say yes,” Mr. McLay recounted in a wide-ranging interview this week at his home. He said he liked the idea of becoming a chief but was sad to leave behind his work for the IACP.

Quietly, some have questioned whether Mr. McLay is ready to make the shift from supervising 60 officers in one section of a Midwestern city to leading about 880 of them in Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

They point, too, to demographic differences between the two cities. At the time of the last census, Madison was 78.9 percent white and 7.3 percent black. Its median household income was about $53,000.

Pittsburgh, by comparison, was 66 percent white and 26.1 percent black. Its average household income was about $15,000 lower.

There also are differences in the number of cases the two departments handle in a given year. According to their annual reports, Madison police last year arrested 7,828 people, and Pittsburgh police arrested 18,541.

Is Mr. McLay ready for the job?

“I think so,” he said while he sat on a white chair in his living room, wearing a red T-shirt and shorts.

Advertise with us

He pointed to the number of calls for service in Pittsburgh last year, about 230,000, and said of the officers, “They already know how to do their officer jobs. What can I do to enhance that?”

That’s similar to what leaders of the Pittsburgh police union have said while defending their members in recent years as morale plummeted and public scrutiny increased amid the federal scandal, shootings and other controversial events.

At this point, most of what Mr. McLay knows about the bureau comes from reading news accounts and from studying annual reports.

Because of that, he said, he preferred not to talk about specifics within the bureau because he hadn’t had a chance to learn its workings for himself. When he does talk about Pittsburgh specifically, he generally refers to policing theories, many of which he used in Madison, as ways to solve Pittsburgh’s problems.

He’s aware from reading media reports that former Chief Nate Harper is serving a federal prison term and that others have been placed on leave since it became public that the FBI was investigating some in the city. He said he knows nothing else of the situation and hopes to quickly find someone with direct knowledge to tell him about what happened during the Harper era and since then.

Advertise with us

Asked whom he will keep and who will go, he believes it will become clear whom to keep as he tries to make changes in the bureau.

“I’m not worried about rooting out bad apples. They will make themselves evident,” he said, adding that he has a theory that the good people in the bureau will unite to change it while others will become loners.

Building relationships is at the core of Mr. McLay’s ideas for solving most of the bureau’s problems.

He said “bridging the divide” between officers and the community will be one of his top priorities, echoing what the mayor and public safety director said they expected from a new chief. His appointment as chief must still be confirmed by city council.

Mr. McLay has seen news articles in which City Councilman Ricky Burgess and others have spoken extensively about the need to repair relationships between the officers and the community. Mr. McLay emailed several community leaders Thursday and said he intended on Friday to reach out to members of the police bureau’s command staff.

Advertise with us

He left open the possibility that the department would work with New York professor David Kennedy to fully implement the Pittsburgh Initiative to Reduce Crime. “Mr. Kennedy’s work, in my opinion, is brilliant. It’s absolutely the key to how you dissolve the gap [between officers and the community].”

He said he recognizes that the bureau has long struggled to recruit a diverse force and that his goal is to build relationships in Pittsburgh communities where more minorities live, ideally reaching the point where the relationships are good enough that minorities want to apply to become officers.

Some changes will probably be influenced by Mr. McLay’s 35 years working in Madison, where the chief similarly talks about the importance of building rapport with residents.

Mr. McLay wasn’t born in Wisconsin. His family moved every few years when he was growing up, often following his father’s job with Alcoa as it took them from New Bronxville, N.Y., where he was born, to Chicago and Cleveland and to Mt. Lebanon between 1971 and 1974. He even spent a few years in England, where he attended his first year of college so he could be on the same continent as his parents.

His family often vacationed in northern Wisconsin, so when he saw an opening for an officer in Madison after he graduated from Indiana University, “I thought, ‘It will be like a vacation if I go.’ ”

Advertise with us

Community-oriented policing, a method that promotes building relationships with residents as a key to reducing crime rates, was already established in the department when he joined.

Three years after he joined the force, he became a member of its SWAT team. After that, he also served on a narcotics and gang squad, often working on rock-cocaine investigations as the drug moved in from Milwaukee, Chicago and other places.

He said one of his favorite moments came a few years ago when thousands of people traveled to the state capitol in Madison to protest increased restrictions on unions. During those protests, officers had access to riot gear and other tactical equipment, but they kept it out of sight.

“We hid those, what we call hard gear,” he said. “What we looked like is exactly what we looked like every day of the week, except we would have some officers wear traffic safety vests” so they stood out in the crowd.

It’s clear even from the first interview that he shares some of the philosophies that the public safety director does – one is that an officer’s appearance plays a large role in how the public perceives him.

Advertise with us

Mr. Bucar is currently clashing with the Pittsburgh police union over proposed changes in officers’ uniforms, such as whether they should wear protective vests inside or outside of their dress shirts and whether they should be permitted to wear baseball-style caps.

Many of Mr. McLay’s initial ideas can be summed up in one notion -- that officers, in his words, should “police like human beings, not let the badge become the barrier.”