The City of Pittsburgh on Friday would not make public documents expected to provide more detail about a Milwaukee consultant’s pending contract with the police bureau that has raised concerns with a councilman there.
Sonya Toler, the public safety spokeswoman, on Thursday gave the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette a partial contract for ESM Advisors LLC, but it did not include an exhibit titled, “Scope of Work Addendum and Fee Schedule.” She declined to explain the omission.
Portions of the contract that were released indicate the exhibit contains additional information about “consultant’s fees, costs and expenses” as well as “services to be provided.” City Council and Mayor Bill Peduto approved hiring ESM Advisors for as much as $32,340 for a wide variety of consulting work, including using data to more strategically deploy officers.
The released documents also suggest the unreleased exhibit contains information about the owner of ESM Advisors, Joel Plant, who is chief of staff for the Milwaukee Police Department, and another person apparently working with him, Daniel Polans. Mr. Polans is listed on his LinkedIn profile as a crime analyst with the department.
Ms. Toler said Friday she could not release the exhibit because the Law Department has the contract. She also said the paperwork that ESM Advisors filed last month with the city in response to a request for proposals was not available because it was with the Law Department.
Bob Donovan, a Milwaukee alderman, on Friday released a statement saying he was surprised to learn that Mr. Plant was being hired as a consultant.
“If Mr. Plant can spend all of that time in Pittsburgh while still doing his job here, I believe it’s time we take another look at his job description, because in my mind this smells strongly of double-dipping at the expense of Milwaukee taxpayers,” Mr. Donovan said.
Mr. Plant, whom the Milwaukee Police Department hired in 2010, is paid $98,434.08 a year.
Two years after Mr. Plant was hired from his previous job as an aide to the mayor of Madison, Wis., the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel ran the first of several pieces exposing chronic and longtime problems with how the Milwaukee Police Department misreported crime statistics.
The newspaper’s stories revealed how the flaws in recording data skewed the city’s crime rate so Milwaukee appeared safer.
A Milwaukee Fire and Police Commission audit found that problems were even more widespread, with more than 5,300 assault cases being misclassified since 2006.
Milwaukee police Chief Edward Flynn blamed human error and computer failures. The department denied that data was altered on purpose, and the audit agreed.
It is unclear what role, if any, Mr. Plant had as chief of staff in overseeing data or implementing fixes to the problem in Milwaukee.
Mr. Plant, who arrived this week in Pittsburgh, could not be reached for comment the past two days.
Pittsburgh acting police Chief Cameron McLay and Mr. Plant knew each other professionally when both worked for the city government in Madison, where the chief was a police captain.
Chief McLay said this week that he sought Mr. Plant’s insight before taking the job in Pittsburgh.
Timothy McNulty, a spokesman for Mr. Peduto, noted that Milwaukee’s data problems predate Mr. Plant’s arrival at the department.
Chief Flynn released a statement Friday that defended the Milwaukee department’s reputation and said Mr. Plant had permission to moonlight. The chief said Mr. Plant was using vacation days to do his consulting work.
“Joel Plant responded to a request for proposal from the City of Pittsburgh and was selected in a public purchasing process,” the statement said. “He has and is taking vacation time and is assisting Pittsburgh as it seeks to learn the lessons from the City of Milwaukee regarding the organizational change process.”
Mr. Plant’s corporation was the sole vendor to respond to a request for proposals soliciting bids to assess and evaluate the Pittsburgh police bureau.
Councilman Daniel Gilman, a strong supporter of using data, said Thursday he was unaware of the Milwaukee police department’s data troubles.
Mr. Gilman said, however, that “there’s a big difference between data collection and data release.”
He said Mr. Plant was being hired to assist with using data rather than classifying it and releasing it to other agencies, such as the FBI, which compiles national crime-report data.
Mr. Gilman acknowledged that council did not grill Chief McLay particularly hard about the ESM Advisors in a council hearing Nov. 10.
“Generally in City Council our concern is whether or not the concept is worthy of tax dollars and whether or not a competitive process to find the best deal for taxpayers was used,” Mr. Gilman said, adding that he and his colleagues trust that city department heads have properly vetted candidates.
“Certainly the issues in Milwaukee sound very serious and concerning, but I would not draw a conclusion on an individual that they are responsible for it or incapable of providing excellent service to Pittsburgh because of it,” Mr. Gilman said.
The Milwaukee police statement touted the department as forward-thinking and shrugged off the Journal Sentinel’s findings.
“Outside the walls of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, the Milwaukee Police Department is widely regarded as an innovative, progressive police department engaged in evidence-based best practices,” the statement said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.