Attorneys for the city of Pittsburgh and two of its police officers filed court motions today in an effort to cut at least $90,000 from a July jury award in a case of excessive force.
The jury in U.S. District Court found that officers Matthew Turko and Robert Smith used excessive force in their December 2010 arrest of Anthony Kenney, 40, of Perry North. The jury awarded Mr. Kenney $5,000 in compensatory damages and $100,000 in punitive damages.
The punitive damage award, wrote the city attorneys, is "grossly excessive, in violation of constitutional due process and federal common law." They asked U.S. Magistrate Judge Lisa Pupo Lenihan to shave it to "at most, $10,000."
The city cited prior court decisions holding that there should be “a single-digit ratio between punitive and compensatory damages,” and that “an award of more than four times the amount of compensatory damages might be close to the line of constitutional impropriety.” They noted that the jury in Mr. Kenney's case awarded punitive damages that were 20 times the compensatory damages, and intimated that they might appeal.
Timothy O'Brien, one of Mr. Kenney's attorneys, countered in a phone interview that there "is no strict proportionality or ratio [between compensatory and punitive damages], particularly in cases in which there were constitutional violations.
"We think the jury's award was perfectly reasonable under the circumstances," Mr. O'Brien said. Mr. Kenney, he said, "was struck in the head for no reason," in violation of his constitutional rights.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.