Five months after a woman's death spurred calls for a policy outlining police response to disconnected 911 calls, Pittsburgh police created one that doesn't satisfy officers, watchdogs or the district attorney.

Several veteran police supervisors and the Allegheny County district attorney said the policy created in response to the death of Ka'Sandra Wade seems to do little more than codify previous practice, and the police union president described it as an unnecessary attempt to regulate what officers already know.

Representatives from the Citizen Police Review Board and Action United, which has been pushing for more forceful policies, said the document lacks the one thing it needed most -- a section requiring officers to make contact with the caller.

Elizabeth Pittinger, executive director of the Citizen Police Review Board, called the policy an "interesting piece," noting that it encourages officers to contact a supervisor on ambiguous calls. She thought that was a positive development.

Advertise with us

Still, she said, "You could conceivably have a person being held hostage against their will. There was no call in this for them to observe the caller, and I think that was one of the major recommendations that the board made."

Maryellen Deckard, who worked as Wade's supervisor at Action United, echoed those thoughts.

"The only thing I didn't see was that if it was a woman talking they wouldn't let a man tell them everything was 'OK.' That's the most important piece, isn't it?" she said.

Deputy police Chief Paul Donaldson said in an email that the policy provides officers with guidelines for steps they can take to reach someone who calls 911, but "you cannot MANDATE contact with an individual, we can only make an effort. No one can be forced to speak with [the] responding officer, and Constitutional guidelines prohibit forced entry without justification."

The policy went into effect May 20 and offers guidelines that suggest officers attempt to learn whether dispatch has the name, gender and rough age of the caller, as well as information about whether there was a struggle and whether the call came from a land-line or cell phone.

Advertise with us

Suggested steps when officers arrive at the scene include knocking on the door, asking for a callback, walking around the building, trying to reach neighbors and looking for cars that might indicate someone is present.

If the officers cannot contact the caller, they should advise a supervisor, who then has the discretion to choose whether they should force entry, according to the policy.

It does not mandate that officers make contact with the caller.

The CPRB sent 12 recommendations to the bureau for consideration, including one suggesting the creation of a policy for responding to disconnected 911 calls.

Allegheny County Emergency Services chief Alvin Henderson is working to create an optional and voluntary system at 911 to flag victims of domestic violence when 911 is dialed from their phone, county spokeswoman Amie Downs said. There is no timetable for its implementation.

Advertise with us

Sgt. Michael LaPorte, president of the officers' union, said he thought the policy was unnecessary.

"It's kindergarten police work," he said. "Do you need to be told what you already know in a formal policy?"

He said he thought the officers in Wade's case acted appropriately, having done everything required in the now formalized policy except for contact a supervisor. He said a shortage of supervisors in the zone on a busy holiday night might have contributed.

He also questioned the reality of trying to create a policy that can account for every situation.

Still, some are pushing for more.

Advertise with us

District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr., who criticized the police response to Wade's call, said the new policy did not address one of his major concerns: officers available on each shift who had specialized training in domestic violence issues.

"That's where I was hoping we would go," said Mr. Zappala, who had not seen the policy.

After a reporter read the policy to Mr. Zappala, he said, "That is the training. All they've done is codify it as a policy."