Pittsburgh police are sending two homicide detectives to California to determine whether a doctor there warned UPMC that John F. Shick posed a danger prior to his March 8 shooting rampage at Western Psychiatric Institute and Clinic.

The doctor, a gastroenterologist affiliated with UCLA Health System, corresponded with Mr. Shick for weeks about complaints regarding his medical treatment at UPMC for what he believed was pancreatitis. Two weeks before the shooting incident, their communication apparently took on a more menacing tone, prompting the California physician to email Mr. Shick's Pittsburgh doctor, Vijay Singh, according to sources close to the investigation.

Investigators are trying to ascertain whether that email from the California physician constituted a warning to UPMC and, if so, what the hospital system did with the information.

Shortly after Mr. Shick fatally shot one person, wounded five others and was killed by police on the first floor of Western Psych, the California doctor sent another email, this one to a friend married to a federal prosecutor in Pittsburgh. In that message, which was turned over to investigators, the doctor wrote that upon learning of the deadly violence he knew immediately the perpetrator had been Mr. Shick and that he had warned Dr. Singh about the potential for danger to both him and to the UPMC medical system.

Advertise with us

Authorities assume Dr. Singh notified his UPMC superiors of the email he received before the shooting. If he did notify others, it is not known what actions were subsequently taken. Dr. Singh, who has a sub-specialty in gastroenterology, did not report the threat to Pittsburgh police.

Paul Wood, a UPMC spokesman, Tuesday night paraphrased a portion of the email to Dr. Singh as saying, "my conclusion is that he's relatively harmless."

"There was nothing in the email that would indicate an explicit ... or impending danger," Mr. Wood said.

Neither UPMC nor law enforcement officials would furnish a copy of the emails in question to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, but sources familiar with the investigation characterized portions of them.

UCLA Health System declined comment because of the ongoing police inquiry.

Advertise with us

In written communications with the California doctor, Mr. Shick, 30, criticized Dr. Singh and UPMC for how they managed his care. Mr. Shick complained that he had been misdiagnosed and that doctors were placating his concerns by giving him medications which he had stopped taking.

Dr. Singh, 41, and Mr. Shick both lived in the Royal York Apartments in Oakland, separated by one floor. Authorities said they had argued in the building.

Reached by phone Tuesday, Dr. Singh said he was busy with patients and could not talk.

When a reporter tried to contact him later, Richard Kidwell, UPMC's senior associate counsel and director of risk management, returned the call for Dr. Singh within minutes. Mr. Kidwell said Dr. Singh would not be talking to any reporter.

David C. Whitcomb, chief of UPMC's division of gastroenterology, hepatology and nutrition, said Tuesday he was "not aware of any particular threat against Dr. Singh" and he was not aware of any warning note sent to Dr. Singh by a California doctor.

Advertise with us

"There are patients that aren't happy with a correct diagnosis ..." he said. "I knew [Mr. Shick] was seen as a patient here and was discharged as a patient. And Dr. Singh, from what I can tell through this thing, has acted extraordinarily professional from everything I know about him.

"The people in our division worked very appropriately and everybody was shocked and saddened by this," he said. "Obviously we had no idea something like this was going to happen. How do you guess about stuff like this? Profilers can't do it."

Investigators have not discovered a motive for Mr. Shick's behavior nor have they come up with an explanation for why he targeted Western Psych. Despite extensive efforts, investigators have been unable to find any links between Mr. Shick and employees at the facility.

One of Dr. Singh's offices is at UPMC Presbyterian, which is across the street from Western Psych, but it is not known whether that played a role in the location of the shooting.

Mr. Shick was educated at elite liberal arts and Ivy League schools but had a history of apparent mental illness. He complained about physical ailments, either real or imagined.

Advertise with us

On Jan. 11, he called 911 to report health problems. At around 5:30 a.m. that day, he told a dispatcher he was vomiting blood and had a stomach ache. He met paramedics in the lobby and was transported to Presby.

Mr. Shick sometimes left yellow Post-Its on his door that said, "Now cleaning up vomit of pancreatitis. Please do not disturb." The room, which few people ever entered, often smelled like cleaning products, residents said.

On March 7, the day before the shootings, Mr. Shick was taken to Presby after calling 911. Records show that he called shortly after 5 p.m. and reported that he was sick. He said that he was throwing up blood and had worms in his stool. He also told them he had a parasitic and subcutaneous infection. He vomited in the lobby, neighbors said, and paramedics took him to the hospital as an E0, the highest priority that can be assigned to a medical transport.

After the shooting, police went to his apartment and found rambling messages written on the walls and in notebooks. In some of the writing, he complained about his medical treatment and what he characterized as their misdiagnoses of his ailments, and his particular displeasure with Dr. Singh.

Covering a table in Mr. Shick's apartment were at least 43 prescription medications to fight ailments such as depression, anxiety, migraines, seizures, chronic kidney disease, impotence, high cholesterol, high blood pressure, intestinal worms, gastric reflux, ulcers, gallbladder trouble, irritable bowel syndrome and chronic pancreatitis. There also were caffeine pills, sedatives, hypothyroid drugs, narcotic painkillers and drugs to treat Hodgkin's disease.

Sources said many of the pills were self-prescribed from online pharmacies overseas.