One of two Pittsburgh police officers who made a narcotics arrest now being investigated by the Allegheny County district attorney's office already was the subject of a probe by the city's Office of Municipal Investigations stemming from a different arrest.

OMI is investigating the circumstances of an arrest in May by Officer Anthony J. Scarpine III, this one at the Municipal Courts Building Downtown.

In that case, Officer Scarpine charged Christinia Condarcure, 46, of North Apollo, with intimidating a witness and simple assault on May 6.

The charges were subsequently dropped by District Judge Robert P. Ravenstahl Jr. on Aug. 4.

Advertise with us

Officer Scarpine wrote in a sworn affidavit that Ms. Condarcure "threw an elbow/forearm" into the chest of a witness who was testifying in a case against her son, Taylor Condarcure, as he left a courtroom.

Officer Scarpine said he was seated in a hallway when Ms. Condarcure caught his attention. He wrote that several officers stepped between the witness, Shannon Deems, and Ms. Condarcure. Officer Scarpine said he arrested Ms. Condarcure outside the courts building.

OMI questioned whether Officer Scarpine actually witnessed the incident.

Investigators have reviewed videotape of the incident and have interviewed sheriff's deputies who were providing security at the courts.

Officer Scarpine has been interviewed by OMI, indicating that the probe is near an end, according to sources familiar with the investigation. OMI Director Kathy Kraus said she could neither confirm nor deny any investigation.

Advertise with us

Officer Scarpine and Officer Ken Simon have been put on "modified duties" with limited contact with the public since the district attorney's office began investigating a pair of narcotics arrests they made in July at a North Side car wash.

The district attorney's office withdrew the drug charges after a surveillance video failed to corroborate statements by the arresting officers, according to sources familiar with that investigation.

At issue is surveillance footage of the arrests taken near the car wash at 2900 Stayton St.

Deputy Chief Paul Donaldson confirmed Officers Scarpine and Simon have been taken off routine patrol but declined to comment about either investigation.

The May incident with Ms. Condarcure had its origins in a February confrontation that Pittsburgh police, moonlighting as security guards outside a Station Square tavern, had with Taylor Condarcure, who was charged with aggravated assault, resisting arrest and defiant trespass.

Advertise with us

Ms. Condarcure's attorney, Michael Foglia, said there was definitely some sort of contact between his client and the alleged victim, Mr. Deems, but said it was not intentional.

"They both came out of the door at the same time and they bumped each other," Mr. Foglia said. "It was just a bumping of the shoulder. They just incidentally bumped each other."

Mr. Foglia said no one was injured. He said his client spent a weekend in jail and had to be evaluated by the behavior clinic.

Asked to reconcile his description of incidental contact with Officer Scarpine's sworn statement that Ms. Condarcure threw an elbow to Mr. Deems, Mr. Foglia said:

"It's a difference in perception. To a police officer looking from a different point of view, it could be an elbow to the chest. They definitely bumped ... From my client's point of view, I don't think she did anything wrong. From Scarpine's point of view, I don't think he did anything wrong [in filing charges]."