City workers arrested for domestic violence would face discipline, and those convicted would be fired, under rules proposed yesterday by Pittsburgh Mayor Luke Ravenstahl.
"That's amazing. It's wonderful," Judy Yupcavage, spokeswoman for the Pennsylvania Coalition Against Domestic Violence, said when told of the mayor's initiative. "First of all, what a great policy to have in place, and what a great message it sends to the citizens of the city that there will be protections in place."
Rules have been in place for police accused of domestic violence for two years. The new, tweaked policy would apply to firefighters, public works employees, paramedics and the rest of the city's 3,300 workers.
Some of the unions representing those workers said they were waiting for the mayor to invite them to discuss the policy.
"Nobody wants to see domestic violence occur at all," said Josh Bloom, a lawyer representing the firefighters union. He welcomed proposed domestic violence awareness training. "However, that doesn't mean that every type of domestic altercation that ever happened in history warrants an employee losing their jobs."
Mr. Ravenstahl's policy comes more than 2 1/2 years after he pledged "zero tolerance" toward domestic abuse by city workers. That was driven by the simultaneous promotions of three police officers who had faced past family abuse allegations, which provoked outrage among women's advocates.
He intends to implement the policy this month and has asked council to make it an ordinance. Nine pages long, it sets out a series of steps triggered by signs of aggressiveness, accusations, arrests and convictions.
An employee who knew that another was involved with "abuse or violence" would have to report it. A supervisor who noted aggressiveness or other signs of domestic trouble in an employee would be required to meet with the employee, report the situation to the bureau or department chief, and a psychological exam and possibly enrollment in a program for abusers would ensue.
An accusation of domestic violence would trigger a city Office of Municipal Investigations probe, while an arrest would compel a Disciplinary Action Report that usually leads to punishment.
"Guilty until proven innocent is not the standard in general society and certainly not the standard in union-management relations," said Mr. Bloom. "Not only is it completely unfair to the employees, but it's unfair to the taxpayers, because a policy like that may create a tremendous amount of back pay and legal fees" when employees are exonerated and brought back to work.
Any "domestic violence incidents" would be reviewed by a board including the directors of public safety and operations, the solicitor, bureau and department chiefs, a psychologist and an adviser from the Women's Center and Shelter. Incidents in which police are accused are heard by a similar, but separate, board.
"This policy is sending a clear message that the mayor takes domestic violence seriously, and it's so encouraging that he's working with victim advocates so that this policy can be implemented in a thoughtful, effective way," said Brian Namey, spokesman for the Washington, D.C.-based National Network to End Domestic Violence.
A conviction for domestic violence would result in an automatic firing.
The city could no longer hire anyone who admitted to, or was found to have had, a history of domestic violence, elder abuse, child abuse, sexual assault or stalking. The city now conducts background checks on all prospective hires.
Mr. Ravenstahl's office noted that Boston has policies dealing with domestic violence by city employees.
Boston's policy, which took effect in 1997, applies only to non-union employees -- a minority of that city's 8,000-strong work force. Any such worker charged with domestic violence or put under a restraining order must go to counseling; a refusal results in administrative leave without pay. Non-union city workers who are convicted of domestic violence or who violate restraining orders are fired.
Toni Troop, spokeswoman for the Massachusetts Coalition Against Sexual Assault and Domestic Violence, said her group has been satisfied with Boston's policy.
She took issue, though, with Mr. Ravenstahl's proposed automatic bar on hiring and mandatory termination upon conviction. "Automatic termination or automatic not-hiring may or may not be in the best interests of that victim," Ms. Troop said. "There are nuances here."
A past conviction for domestic violence does not necessarily prohibit employment in Boston.
If there were a domestic-violence incident in the distant past of a prospective employee and that person is on the "right track," said William Kessler, Boston's assistant director of the Office of Human Resources, "We'd probably be willing to hire that person."
Mr. Ravenstahl's proposal came a day after he fired Eugene Hlavac, until then a police sergeant and one of those promoted in 2007. His ex-girlfriend accused him last month of dislocating her jaw in a dispute, and he has denied wrongdoing. He faces simple assault charges, and if convicted would be barred from policing in Pennsylvania.
"We disagree entirely with the city and the mayor with regards to Sgt. Hlavac's termination," said Mr. Hlavac's attorney, Phillip P. DiLucente, in a statement sent by e-mail yesterday, adding that the city "will have to deal with the future consequences of the improper action taken [Thursday] and the continued violation of my client's rights."



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.