John Heller, Post-Gazette

Alonna Cuffe, 13, offers a prayer yesterday at a makeshift memorial at Bennett Street and North Lang Avenue in Homewood, site of Thursday night's crash.

An unmarked police car involved in a chase in Homewood was 11/2 blocks away when the suspect vehicle ran a red light and crashed, killing two people in another car, a police supervisor said yesterday.

Lt. Philip J. Dacey, acting commander of the East Liberty station, said the police car's lights and siren were activated during the incident.

Advertise with us

Some who said they witnessed the chase and the crash at Bennett Street and North Lang Avenue claimed the police car's siren was not activated, which would be against departmental policy.

Lt. Dacey said it would not have mattered, and said blame for the crash lay squarely on the fleeing driver, Devon Miles, 20, of Kelly Street in Homewood.

"Even if they didn't [have the siren activated], it wouldn't have made a difference because they weren't involved in the accident. Those lights and sirens wouldn't have cleared the intersection," Lt. Dacey said yesterday. The suspect "made a conscious decision to run through that red light."

Killed in the crash were Michelle A. Rankin, 35, of Wilkinsburg, and Jerome D. Smith, 34, of Stanton Heights. Both died of head and chest injuries.

Ms. Rankin was driving east in a Ford Escort on Bennett Street when, police said, Mr. Miles drove his pickup truck north through a red light on Lang and smashed into the passenger side.

Advertise with us

Police said the impact drove the Escort into a van with three adults and three children, all of whom were injured. Their identities were not released by authorities.

Mr. Miles, who tried to run away but was quickly apprehended at gunpoint, had a .38-caliber revolver and suspected crack cocaine and marijuana, police said. He was covered with white paint, two 5-gallon cans of which had been inside Ms. Rankin's vehicle and exploded upon impact.

He was charged with two counts of homicide by vehicle, carrying a firearm without a license, drug offenses and numerous traffic violations, including driving without a license. He was arraigned in Pittsburgh Municipal Court and held on $250,000 straight bond.

Mr. Miles appears to have no criminal record other than being cited April 12 for driving without a license on Formosa Way.

Tempera Frazier, 66, Mrs. Rankin's neighbor of 12 years, said the victim had been preparing for a Memorial Day party at her house on McNary Boulevard. She had returned the other day with topsoil for her back yard.

Advertise with us

Mrs. Rankin apparently planned to repaint a portion of her house yesterday.

Mrs. Frazier said Mrs. Rankin fancied herself a neighborhood overseer and would often tell neighbors to cut their lawns and take care of their homes so they could "keep the properties up."

She said Mrs. Rankin sang in the choir at Mount Ararat Baptist Church in Larimer, and at weddings.

"She had a sweet voice," said Marsha Frazier, Mrs. Frazier's daughter.

The Rev. Hubert Hutcherson of Shiloh Community Missionary Baptist Church in Homewood said everywhere he went yesterday, people were discussing and mourning the crash.

Advertise with us

"I've been sitting here all day, thinking about what to say to my congregation [tomorrow]. It bothers me, not only that a young man threw his life away, but innocent lives are lost,'' the pastor said.

The pastor said he also heard divergent opinions -- some people criticized the police, while others supported their efforts to drive crime from their neighborhoods.

Thursday's incident began around 6 p.m. when an unmarked police car was on patrol in Homewood. Inside were officers Sean Rattigan, who was driving, Robert Pires and Jerry Kabala.

Lt. Dacey said the officers noticed the pickup truck with inoperable brake lights on Homewood Avenue and decided to pull it over. They turned onto Hamilton Avenue, which is when the officers believe the driver realized who they were.

The officers activated their emergency lights and siren, Lt. Dacey said. The pickup truck pulled over, and the officers pulled behind it.

Advertise with us

But the driver never turned off the engine. Instead, he began moving again, turned the corner onto Lang and then gunned the engine and took off.

The truck, a Chevy Colorado, went through a green light at Kelly Street. By the time it got to the next major intersection -- Bennett Street -- the light there was red.

People in the neighborhood, which has numerous homes, several churches, a YMCA and a funeral home, acknowledged that police had a job to do. Some questioned the wisdom of chasing suspects through the residential area. But most were inclined to blame the driver, not the police.

"I think it was the guy's fault," said Shawnette Wright, 37, who lives on the corner of the crash. She insisted that she heard no siren before the collision.

"The idea is that he was going to go through that light whether the police were after him or not," said William Maben, another resident of the corner. "The police pursuits we're concerned about are the ones that start in East Liberty and come through here at 100 mph."

Advertise with us

That tone was in contrast to bystanders' comments made shortly after the crash that took police to task. Many officers working in Zone 5 bristled at their comments.

Officers Rattigan, Pires and Kabala were put on two days of administrative leave, which is standard procedure. Detectives from the homicide squad and collision investigation unit are handling the case, and their work is being overseen by the district attorney's office.

A critical review board comprising three senior police supervisors will review the incident to determine if rules and regulations were followed and if any discipline or retraining should be recommended to Police Chief Dominic J. Costa.

Assistant Chief Paul Donaldson said the officers involved were justified in initiating a pursuit because Mr. Miles tried to avoid apprehension.

"The time between the initial pullover and the accident was three to six seconds and it occurred in less than 300 feet. It wasn't a pursuit,'' he said. "But would we have pursued? Probably.''

Advertise with us

He said officers who begin a chase must broadcast their location and reason for the chase. A supervisor then must monitor it on the police radio.

Officer Pires had time only to put out a snippet of information on police radio -- accidentally on the wrong channel -- before the crash occurred, Lt. Dacey said.

Lt. Dacey estimated that the officers involved in Thursday's pursuit might pull over a half-dozen cars during one shift.

"We do a couple hundred traffic stops a week and most of them are uneventful. We have three, four, five chases a week. We had a chase later that night on the other end of Homewood," he said.

At the accident scene yesterday, Jeannette Turner, 40, of Penn Hills, whose son was killed in 2003, stopped by with her husband, John, a barbershop manager, to tie a sympathy card, artificial flowers and a teddy bear to a utility pole on the corner.

Advertise with us

"This is for the family," Mrs. Turner said. "I always think you should do something nice, just to hold the family up, just to help them."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.