A jury yesterday failed to reach a decision in the penalty phase of Alvin Starks' murder trial, sparing the man from death by lethal injection.

Mr. Starks, convicted last week in the 2004 killing of his ex-fiancee, 33-year-old Andrea "Andie" Umphrey, showed no emotion as jurors announced they were hopelessly deadlocked after two days of discussions on whether he should live or die.

Common Pleas Senior Judge Robert E. Colville dismissed the jury, seven men and five women, and set March 1 as a sentencing date. Mr. Starks, 32, faces life in prison.

On April 18, 2004, Mr. Starks abducted Ms. Umphrey and their 9-month-old daughter at gunpoint during a service at Victorious Faith Evangelic Outreach Church in Sheraden. After a 50-mile police chase that ended at the Pennsylvania Turnpike toll booth in Monroeville, he shot Ms. Umphrey, a mother of three who worked as an accountant.

Advertise with us

Yesterday, about a dozen friends and relatives of Ms. Umphrey gathered in the courtroom and took turns embracing the woman's mother, Audrey. One friend held her head in her hands and wept.

Lisa G. Middleman, Mr. Starks' defense attorney, speculated that a few jurors reflected on the depth of her client's troubled past as they considered imposing the death penalty.

"There are some people in this world that understand and appreciate that the deprivation of love can devastate a human being," she said.

During the trial, prosecutors presented journal entries showing that Mr. Starks had threatened to kill Ms. Umphrey if she tried to take their child away from him.

Mr. Starks testified that his gun discharged accidentally in the killing, and he told relatives that he deeply loved Ms. Umphrey. In a letter to his father, he wrote, "If she's not here, I don't want to be here," according to his twin brother, Marvin, who traveled from Lewisburg, Union County, to hear the jury's verdict.

Advertise with us

Marvin Starks said his brother's demeanor yesterday suggested that he wanted to die.

"That was his love. That was his soulmate," Marvin Starks said of Ms. Umphrey. "I don't think he wanted to live thinking about this anymore."

Still, his brother said, "I'm glad they spared his life."

In addition to capital murder, Alvin Starks also faces sentencing for weapons violation, fleeing and eluding police, reckless endangerment, simple assault, five counts of aggravated assault, and two counts each of attempted homicide, kidnapping, and making terroristic threats.