It's Pittsburgh's Sing Sing or Alcatraz.
Though officially called the State Correctional Institution Pittsburgh, most local folks know it as Western Pen, short for the prison's original name, Western State Penitentiary. To employees and inmates alike, the foreboding structure on the Ohio River is known as "The Big House" and "The Wall."
Darrell Sapp, Post-Gazette
This is a view of the D Unit, formerly known at the South Block, at the State Correctional Institution Pittsburgh in Woods Run.
Click photo for larger image.
Related coverage
Closed for business: The last days of Western Pen
A month from now, the final prisoners and most of the employees will be gone, transferred to other institutions as the prison shuts down operations after 122 years. The state Department of Corrections plans to mothball the prison, in the city's Woods Run section, for at least three years with a skeleton crew of mostly maintenance workers in the event its 1,100 cells are needed again.
State officials are mulling the idea of opening Western Pen for public tours, such as occurred when the old Allegheny County Jail closed in 1998, said Sue McNaughton, spokeswoman for the Department of Corrections in Camp Hill.
Little by little, inmates and employees have trickled out of the prison to other institutions over the past 13 months. Some veteran corrections employees have opted to retire rather than face long commutes to new prisons in Fayette and Forest counties.
When the last inmate leaves, an event scheduled for Jan. 15, it will mark the first time since 1826 that state prisoners have not been incarcerated in Pittsburgh.
"I just feel so bad that this place is closing. It's like a death in the family," said Capt. Pamela K. Teeter, 43, of Ross, who has worked at the prison for nearly 20 years. "It will be a humbling experience for all of us. It's just sad to see it ending."
As far back as 1911, state officials have threatened to close the prison. Each time, the reasons were the same: It was too expensive to operate, it was falling apart and it was too prone to flooding.
Like the prisoners housed within its 40-foot sandstone walls, Western Pen received many reprieves. But the prison's prolonged death sentence picked up speed nearly eight years ago when six inmates tunneled their way to short-lived freedom. The 19th century prison came under attack after the escape from top state corrections officials in an assault that never really lost momentum.
Many state and local elected officeholders joined forces with corrections employee unions to try to stop the closure through hearings and meetings over the past few years. Their efforts worked only to delay the inevitable.
"Pittsburgh's already got many problems and this is just making it worse," said Ed McConnell, executive vice president of the Pennsylvania State Corrections Officers Association in Camp Hill, which represented 780 Western Pen employees last year.
1962 photo
Guards count prisoners in the Home Block at Western Pen.
Click photo for larger image.
McConnell cited the loss to the city of occupation and wage taxes of the prison's employees, as well as the economic loss to restaurants, gas stations and other businesses as those jobs disappear.
But not everyone is sad about the prison's closing.
Lawyer Jere Krakoff said he thought the prison should have been closed in the late 1980s, when he and other civil rights lawyers filed a class action lawsuit against the state on behalf of inmates because of crowding and deplorable prison conditions. The lawsuit ended in 1997, after 10 years and more than $100 million in improvements to Western Pen, including a new hospital and fire safety and ventilation renovations.
"In some ways, it was inevitable that they couldn't continue operating the prison, and the DOC should have realized it at the time instead of spending all that money [on improvements]," Krakoff said. "I didn't take any great comfort in that."
The first Western Pen opened in July 1826 on the site of the National Aviary on the North Side. It was the first prison to house inmates separately in isolation, a penal method that became known as the Pennsylvania system. A second, larger prison was built on the same site several years later and operated until the Woods Run prison opened in 1882.
By the time the new prison opened, state prison officials had adopted the Auburn system in Pittsburgh instead of the Pennsylvania system. Named after a New York prison that opened in 1819, the Auburn system allowed inmates to mix during the day instead of being relegated to isolation 24 hours a day.
The Woods Run prison was built with a Gothic architectural style that caused many news reports throughout its first 100 years to describe it as "medieval looking." The 640-cell North Block was the first to open, followed by the South Block three years later.
Until the blocks were renovated in the mid-1990s as a result of the prisoner lawsuit, the prison could have been a set for an old gangster movie. The cells were in long corridors on five tiers, with half the cells facing the inside of the prison and the others facing the Ohio River. The expansive layout presented security issues for guards and inmates alike.
The North and South blocks were partitioned in half in 1995 and 1996 so guards would be responsible for smaller areas. New prisons, such as those that opened recently in Fayette and Forest counties, are designed so the inmates are housed in much smaller, semicircular areas called pods which permit guards to see every cell at once.
1962 photo
The guard towers at the prison are unmanned now.
Click photo for larger image.
Sgt. Dave Mutchler's first permanent assignment at the prison was on the South Block about a year after he started at Western Pen in '83. Mutchler, 49, of West Deer, was hired at the prison after being laid off at the former Volkswagen plant in New Stanton. The new job was a lot different from his old job, he said.
"Nobody I knew grew up wanting to be a prison guard," he said. "For a new [guard], going into a job like that, it was a real eye-opener."
One of his first "eye-opening" experiences was when a superior directed Mutchler to clean up a pool of blood outside the inmate dining hall that was the result of a fatal stabbing.
Mutchler is one of the prison employees who is opting for retirement rather than a transfer. Currently on medical leave, he plans to retire in March.
The prison exterior remained much the same until the late 1980s, when a new administration building, warehouse and two new cell blocks were built. Construction of the new administration building resulted in a switch of the prison entrance from the Ohio River side of the prison to the side that faces Beaver Avenue, thereby cutting visitors off from the Gothic structures built in the 19th century.
In 1987, two significant events occurred which focused state attention on the prison's conditions: A series of fires and disturbances, and a lawsuit filed by inmate Major Tillery. It was Tillery's lawsuit that caught the attention of Krakoff, who was in Washington, D.C., working for the American Civil Liberties Union's National Prison Project at the time.
The prison was drastically crowded with 2,200 inmates in space provided for about two-thirds that number. Inmates were double-celled and even the guards protested because of their concerns about security.
Conditions at the prison caused now-Senior U.S. District Judge Maurice B. Cohill Jr. to declare the conditions unconstitutional and to call the prison an "overcrowded, insanitary and understaffed firetrap" in a 1989 opinion in which he ordered sweeping changes.
"I'd been in a number of prison facilities and I thought it was one of the worst ones I had ever seen," Krakoff said. "It really was a firetrap. It's a wonder no one died in that place."
As a result, the state spent more than $100 million to renovate the North and South blocks and to build a hospital and special needs unit for the mentally ill, among other things. But still, there were voices in Harrisburg calling for Western Pen to close its doors.
One of the most often cited reasons for the prison's closing has been its per-inmate cost. State officials not too long ago said the prison had the highest prisoner costs in the state.
Records from the Department of Corrections, however, show there are eight other institutions among the 28 state prisons with higher annual prisoner costs than Western Pen's $33,333.
But it is the oldest prison in the state and its location on a flood plain has only contributed to its problems.
The Ohio River has invaded the prison's 12 1/2 acres many times over the years, including a flood that occurred two years after it opened. Beginning in the early 1900s, every flood brought a new call from state officials to close the prison. The most recent flooding occurred in 1996.
A year later, the escape of six inmates who tunneled out of the prison into a warehouse that was outside the walls brought a new cry to shut down Western Pen. The escape was one of a handful of times inmates tunneled out of the prison. There have been many other escapes by other routes, including inmates who have used ladders to scale the wall and who have stowed away in delivery trucks.
One unsuccessful attempt to tunnel out of the prison involved Alexander Berkman in 1900, eight years after he attempted to kill Henry Clay Frick at Frick's Downtown office during the Homestead steel strike. Berkman's tunnel was discovered before he was able to make his escape.
Unlike Berkman, the six inmates who escaped Jan. 8, 1997, made it outside the walls, but were caught within two weeks in Texas. A report issued several weeks later concluded the escape was preventable and was the result of inadequate security that conflicted with state policy, particularly regarding the movement of inmates and the control of tools.
The critical report gave Martin Horn, the corrections secretary at the time, all the ammunition he needed to push the administration of then-Gov. Tom Ridge for a new prison. By October 1997, the Legislature approved $135.4 million for a new prison for southwestern Pennsylvania.
That prison was built in Luzerne, Fayette County. The new prison, which has a capacity for 1,914 inmates, opened in August 2003. Most of Western Pen's employees and inmates went there.
The transfers to Fayette and another new prison in Forest County have created a hardship for the employees, most of whom live in the Pittsburgh area and will have to drive 90 minutes to two hours to work, said McConnell, of the corrections officers union. The union has filed grievances over what it contends was the state's failure to follow seniority requirements in the transfers, a claim corrections spokeswoman McNaughton denies.
The relocation of employees from Pittsburgh was complicated by the fact that the state prison in Waynesburg closed last year and 228 employees at that institution had to transfer to new jobs, McNaughton said.
Dave McCoy, 51, of Morningside, has worked as a drug and alcohol treatment supervisor at Western Pen for seven years. He starts his new job tomorrow as a unit manager at the State Correctional Institution Forest. McCoy will stay during the week in an apartment in Marienville and return home on the weekends.
McCoy, the former chief union steward for his Service Employees International Union local at Western Pen who helped lobby to keep the prison open, called the prison's closing a "sad, sad day."
"I just think that there was a unique blend of personalities at SCI Pittsburgh that I don't think will be duplicated anywhere else," McCoy said. "We just handled the pressures of working in a maximum security prison on a daily basis very well."
Teeter begins her new job Jan. 3 at the state prison in Greensburg. Like other transfers, Teeter will lose her seniority and begin at Greensburg at the bottom of the seniority list among seven captains. Like McCoy and Mutchler, Teeter said her co-workers were what she would miss the most about Western Pen.
"I am a Christian, and I have total faith in God," Teeter said. "I guess what I'm struggling with now is, I guess you never really understand how close you get with the people you work with until something like this happens."
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.